Zylberberg B, Dormont D, Janklewicz S, Daraï E, Madelenat P, Antoine J M
Service de gynécologie, groupe hospitalier Bichat-Claude-Bernard, Paris, France.
Gynecol Obstet Fertil. 2000 Feb;28(2):127-36.
The aim of this study was to investigate the potential benefit of secondary cytoreductive surgery for recurrent ovarian cancer.
Between 1980 and 1993, 85 patients (11 stage Ic, 4 stage IIc, 70 stage III) with an epithelial ovarian cancer were treated after initial surgery with an intraperitoneal and intravenous Cis Platin-based immunochemotherapy. Twenty patients of the 41 who relapsed underwent secondary cytoreductive surgery.
Complete resection was achieved in 13 patients (65%) and was optimal with a < 0.5 cm residual disease left in one case. One patient died postoperatively. Surgery was suboptimal for six patients (30%). At a mean follow-up from recurrence of more than 54 months for the surviving patients, five of the 20 reoperated are still alive. All 21 patients who were not reoperated died with a median survival time from recurrence of eight months (10.5 months for the patients who refused to be reoperated and seven months for the patients rejected by the surgeons) against 29 for the 20 reoperated patients (P < 0.004).
This series is too small to enable us to draw definitive conclusions. Nevertheless, our results seem to suggest the interest of secondary cytoreductive surgery. Indeed, only reoperated patients, above all if surgery was complete or at least optimal, have a chance of long survival. In our opinion, secondary surgical procedure should be proposed to relapsing patients to enhance efficacy of rescue chemotherapy, which is of limited value in bulky tumors.
本研究的目的是调查二次细胞减灭术对复发性卵巢癌的潜在益处。
1980年至1993年间,85例上皮性卵巢癌患者(11例Ic期,4例IIc期,70例III期)在初次手术后接受了以顺铂为基础的腹腔和静脉免疫化疗。41例复发患者中有20例接受了二次细胞减灭术。
13例患者(65%)实现了完全切除,其中1例残留病灶<0.5 cm,达到最佳切除效果。1例患者术后死亡。6例患者(30%)的手术效果欠佳。存活患者从复发开始的平均随访时间超过54个月,20例再次手术的患者中有5例仍存活。所有21例未再次手术的患者均死亡,复发后的中位生存时间为8个月(拒绝再次手术的患者为10.5个月,被外科医生拒绝手术的患者为7个月),而20例再次手术的患者为29个月(P<0.004)。
本系列病例数量太少,无法得出明确结论。然而,我们的结果似乎表明二次细胞减灭术有一定意义。确实,只有再次手术的患者,尤其是手术完全或至少达到最佳效果的患者,才有长期生存的机会。我们认为,对于复发患者应建议进行二次手术,以提高挽救性化疗的疗效,挽救性化疗在大块肿瘤中的价值有限。