Doyle L, Davis P
The Division of Newborn Services, the Royal Women's Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
J Paediatr Child Health. 2000 Apr;36(2):101-7. doi: 10.1046/j.1440-1754.2000.00481.x.
Postnatal corticosteroid therapy has been proved in randomized controlled trials to reduce ventilator dependence and the rate of chronic lung disease in preterm infants with few serious short-term side effects. However, there are other consequences that might follow postnatal corticosteroid therapy that are more important, including mortality or cerebral palsy.
To review the evidence from reported randomized controlled trials on the effects of postnatal corticosteroid on long-term mortality and motor dysfunction, including cerebral palsy.
The methods involved a meta-analysis of reported randomized controlled trials, following guidelines of the Cochrane Collaboration, including calculation of event rate differences (ERD) and 95% confidence intervals (CI).
The mortality rate difference was non-significant both statistically and clinically (ERD - 0.1% favouring corticosteroids, 95% CI -2.9% to 2.8%). There were no subgroups in which a beneficial effect of postnatal corticosteroids on survival could be demonstrated. The rate of motor dysfunction in survivors was significantly higher in survivors from the postnatal corticosteroid group (ERD 11.9% favouring controls, 95% CI 4.6% to 19.2%). The rate of survival, free of motor dysfunction, was significantly lower in the postnatal corticosteroid group (ERD 7.8% favouring controls, 95% CI 0.5% to 15.1%).
Although postnatal corticosteroids have short-term benefits, they do not increase the survival rate, and they may cause motor dysfunction in survivors. A large-scale, placebo-controlled randomized trial, with survival free of sensorineural impairments and disabilities as the major endpoint, is urgently needed.
随机对照试验已证实,产后使用皮质类固醇疗法可减少早产儿对呼吸机的依赖,并降低慢性肺病的发生率,且几乎没有严重的短期副作用。然而,产后使用皮质类固醇疗法可能会带来其他更重要的后果,包括死亡率或脑瘫。
综述已发表的随机对照试验中关于产后使用皮质类固醇对长期死亡率和运动功能障碍(包括脑瘫)影响的证据。
按照Cochrane协作网的指南,对已发表的随机对照试验进行荟萃分析,包括计算事件率差异(ERD)和95%置信区间(CI)。
死亡率差异在统计学和临床上均无显著性(ERD -0.1%,支持皮质类固醇,95%CI -2.9%至2.8%)。没有亚组能够证明产后使用皮质类固醇对生存有有益影响。产后皮质类固醇组幸存者的运动功能障碍发生率显著更高(ERD 11.9%,支持对照组,95%CI 4.6%至19.2%)。产后皮质类固醇组无运动功能障碍的生存率显著更低(ERD 7.8%,支持对照组,95%CI 0.5%至15.1%)。
尽管产后使用皮质类固醇有短期益处,但它们不会提高生存率,且可能导致幸存者出现运动功能障碍。迫切需要进行一项大规模、安慰剂对照的随机试验,以无感觉神经性损伤和残疾的生存作为主要终点。