Nandi D N, Banerjee G, Mukherjee S P, Ghosh A, Nandi P S, Nandi S
Girindrasekhar Clinic, Calcutta, India.
Br J Psychiatry. 2000 Apr;176:351-6. doi: 10.1192/bjp.176.4.351.
Cross-sectional studies give no indication of the changes that may occur in the mental health status of a community in course of times. Studies should be designed to assess these changes.
To assess the changes, if any, in the prevalence of mental disorders in a rural community after an interval of 20 years in the context of its changing socio-economic conditions.
A door-to-door survey of the prevalence of psychiatric morbidity in two villages was conducted by a team of psychiatrists. The survey was repeated after 20 years by the same team and by the same method. Changes in the mental health status of the community were compared.
Total morbidity per 1000 fell from 116.8 to 105.2. Morbidity in men fell from 86.9 to 73.5 per 1000 and in women from 146.8 to 138.3 per 1000. Rates of anxiety, hysteria and phobia had fallen dramatically and those of depression and mania had risen significantly.
The level of psychiatric morbidity showed no statistically significant change. The morbidity pattern (relative proportion of type of morbidity), however, showed some interesting changes. Similar studies should be done on a larger sample.
横断面研究无法表明一个社区的心理健康状况会随时间发生哪些变化。应设计研究来评估这些变化。
在社会经济状况不断变化的背景下,评估一个农村社区在时隔20年后精神障碍患病率是否发生了变化(若有变化)。
一个精神科医生团队对两个村庄的精神疾病患病率进行了挨家挨户的调查。20年后,同一团队采用相同方法重复了该调查。对社区心理健康状况的变化进行了比较。
每1000人的总发病率从116.8降至105.2。男性发病率从每1000人86.9降至73.5,女性发病率从每1000人146.8降至138.3。焦虑症、癔症和恐惧症的发病率大幅下降,而抑郁症和躁狂症的发病率显著上升。
精神疾病发病率水平无统计学上的显著变化。然而,发病模式(发病率类型的相对比例)显示出一些有趣的变化。应在更大样本上开展类似研究。