Illsley R, Hall M H
Bull World Health Organ. 1976;53(1):83-106.
The literature on psychosocial aspects of abortion is confusing. Individual publications must be interpreted in the context of cultural, religious, and legal constraints obtaining in a particular society at a given time, with due attention to the status and availability of alternatives to abortion that might be chosen by a woman with an "unwanted" pregnancy. A review of the literature shows that, where careful pre- and post-abortion assessments are made, the evidence is that psychological benefit commonly results, and serious adverse emotional sequelae are rare. The outcome of refused abortion seems less satisfactory, with regrets and distress frequently occurring. Research on the administration of abortion services suggests that counselling is often of value, that distress is frequently caused by delays in deciding upon and in carrying out abortions, and by unsympathetic attitudes of service providers. The phenomenon of repeated abortion seeking should be seen in the context of the availability and cost of contraception and sterilization. The place of sterilization with abortion requires careful study. A recommendation is made for observational descriptive research on populations of women with potentially unwanted pregnancies in different cultures, with comparisons of management systems and an evaluation of their impact on service users.
关于堕胎心理社会层面的文献令人困惑。必须在特定社会特定时期的文化、宗教和法律限制背景下解读个别出版物,同时要充分关注有“意外”怀孕的女性可能选择的堕胎替代方案的状况和可及性。文献综述表明,在进行仔细的堕胎前和堕胎后评估的情况下,有证据显示通常会带来心理益处,严重的不良情绪后遗症很少见。拒绝堕胎的结果似乎不太令人满意,后悔和痛苦经常出现。关于堕胎服务管理的研究表明,咨询往往有价值,决定和实施堕胎的延迟以及服务提供者缺乏同情心的态度常常会导致痛苦。反复寻求堕胎的现象应结合避孕和绝育的可及性及成本来审视。堕胎时绝育的问题需要仔细研究。建议对不同文化中可能有意外怀孕情况的女性群体开展观察性描述研究,比较管理系统并评估其对服务使用者的影响。