Delgado P D, Cogolludo F J, Mateo O, Cancela P, García R, Carrillo R
Servicio de Neurocirugía, Hospital General Universitario Gregorio Marañón, Madrid, España.
Rev Neurol. 2000;30(9):811-7.
In the literature there is evidence relating different factors such as age and preoperative clinical condition with prognosis in patients treated surgically for chronic subdural haematoma.
To clarify and quantify the magnitude of the factors which determine early prognosis (during hospital admission) of these patients.
We made a prospective study of 137 patients who had been operated on in our centre and found the relationship between different clinical and therapeutic variables with the clinical course and morbidity-mortality by means of multivariate and survival analysis.
A high Markwalder functional score (3-4) is an independent factor of poor prognosis (OR = 13.15; CI 95% 6.1-28.4; p = 0.01), as is the presence of a coexisting coagulopathy (OR = 27.2; CI 95% 9.3-79.5; p = 0.01). Advanced age tended to increase the risk (OR = 1.104) but did not reach statistical significance (p = 0.0654). A multivariate logistic model, which included the functional score and presence of coagulopathy, correctly classified 94.7% of the cases studied. Analysis of survival showed two groups with different early mortality as a function of the Markwalder score (high: 3-4 and low: 0-1-2), which could be differentiated statistically (Log-Rank chi squared test: 3.95; p = 0.0468).
The preoperative clinical state classified by functional scores and the presence of underlying coagulopathy are the main prognostic factors in chronic subdural haematoma during hospital admission. Advanced age is probably not in itself an independent factor for bad prognosis.
文献中有证据表明,在接受慢性硬膜下血肿手术治疗的患者中,年龄和术前临床状况等不同因素与预后相关。
明确并量化决定这些患者早期预后(住院期间)的因素的影响程度。
我们对在本中心接受手术的137例患者进行了前瞻性研究,并通过多变量和生存分析,发现不同临床和治疗变量与临床病程及发病率-死亡率之间的关系。
马克瓦尔德功能评分高(3 - 4分)是预后不良的独立因素(OR = 13.15;95%置信区间6.1 - 28.4;p = 0.01),并存凝血病也是如此(OR = 27.2;95%置信区间9.3 - 79.5;p = 0.01)。高龄倾向于增加风险(OR = 1.104),但未达到统计学显著性(p = 0.0654)。一个包含功能评分和凝血病存在情况的多变量逻辑模型正确分类了94.7%的研究病例。生存分析显示,根据马克瓦尔德评分(高:3 - 4分和低:0 - 1 - 2分)有两组不同的早期死亡率,且可进行统计学区分(对数秩卡方检验:3.95;p = 0.0468)。
通过功能评分分类的术前临床状态和潜在凝血病的存在是慢性硬膜下血肿患者住院期间的主要预后因素。高龄本身可能不是预后不良的独立因素。