Shih T M, McDonough J H
Pharmacology Division, US Army Medical Research Institute of Chemical Defense, Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21010-5400, USA.
Arch Toxicol. 2000 May;74(3):165-72. doi: 10.1007/s002040050670.
The ability of the nerve agents tabun, sarin, soman, GF, VR, and VX to produce brain seizures and the effectiveness of the anticholinergics biperiden HCl or atropine SO4 as an anticonvulsant treatment were studied in a guinea-pig model. All animals were implanted a week prior to the experiment with cortical electrodes for electroencephalogram (EEG) recordings. On the day of exposure, the animals were pretreated with pyridostigmine (0.026 mg/kg, i.m.) 30 min prior to challenge with a 2 x LD50 dose (s.c.) of a given agent. In separate experiments, animals were challenged with 5 x LD50 (s.c.) of soman. One minute after agent challenge, the animals were treated intramuscularly (i.m.) with 2 mg/kg atropine SO4 admixed with 25 mg/kg 2-PAM Cl and then observed for the onset of seizure activity. Five minutes after the start of nerve agent-induced EEG seizures, animals were treated i.m. with different doses of biperiden HCl or atropine SO4 and observed for seizure termination. The anticonvulsant ED50 of biperiden HCl and atropine SO4 for termination of seizures induced by each nerve agent was calculated and compared. With equally toxic doses (2 x LD50) of these agents, continuous EEG seizures (status epilepticus) developed in all animals challenged with soman, tabun, or VR, and in more than 90% of the animals challenged with GF or sarin. In contrast, only 50% of the animals developed seizures when challenged with VX. The times to onset of seizures for soman, tabun, GF, and sarin were very similar (5-8 min) while for VR, it was about 10 min. In the case of VX, not only was the time to seizure development longer (20.7 min), but the seizure activity in 19% of the animals terminated spontaneously within 5 min after onset and did not return. Under these conditions, the anticonvulsant ED50s of biperiden HCl for soman, GF, VR, tabun, sarin, and VX were 0.57, 0.51, 0.41, 0.2, 0.1, and 0.09 mg/kg, respectively, while those of atropine SO4 for soman, VR, tabun, GF, sarin, and VX were 12.2, 11.9, 10.4, 10.3, 5.1, and 4.1 mg/kg, respectively. In separate experiments, the anticonvulsant ED50 doses of biperiden for animals challenged with 2 or 5 x LD50 of soman were 0.48 (95% confidence limits 0.25-0.73) or 0.57 (95% CI 0.38-0.84) mg/kg, respectively, while the anticonvulsant ED50s for atropine (12.2 mg/kg, i.m.) were identical under these same two challenge conditions. The present study demonstrates that all nerve agents can produce status epilepticus and that the therapeutic effectiveness of atropine and biperiden roughly paralleled the seizurogenic potential of these agents.
在豚鼠模型中研究了塔崩、沙林、梭曼、GF、VR和VX等神经毒剂引发脑癫痫发作的能力,以及抗胆碱能药物盐酸苯哌利多或硫酸阿托品作为抗惊厥治疗的有效性。所有动物在实验前一周植入皮质电极用于脑电图(EEG)记录。在暴露当天,动物在接受给定毒剂2倍半数致死剂量(皮下注射)攻击前30分钟,先用吡啶斯的明(0.026mg/kg,肌肉注射)预处理。在单独的实验中,动物接受5倍半数致死剂量(皮下注射)的梭曼攻击。在毒剂攻击1分钟后,给动物肌肉注射2mg/kg硫酸阿托品与25mg/kg氯解磷定的混合液,然后观察癫痫发作活动的开始情况。在神经毒剂诱发EEG癫痫发作开始5分钟后,给动物肌肉注射不同剂量的盐酸苯哌利多或硫酸阿托品,并观察癫痫发作的终止情况。计算并比较盐酸苯哌利多和硫酸阿托品对每种神经毒剂诱发癫痫发作终止的抗惊厥半数有效剂量(ED50)。用这些毒剂的同等毒性剂量(2倍半数致死剂量)攻击时,所有接受梭曼、塔崩或VR攻击的动物以及超过90%接受GF或沙林攻击的动物都出现了持续性EEG癫痫发作(癫痫持续状态)。相比之下,接受VX攻击的动物只有50%出现癫痫发作。梭曼、塔崩、GF和沙林的癫痫发作开始时间非常相似(5 - 8分钟),而VR的癫痫发作开始时间约为10分钟。对于VX,不仅癫痫发作发展时间更长(20.7分钟),而且19%的动物在发作后5分钟内癫痫活动自发终止且未再发作。在这些条件下,盐酸苯哌利多对梭曼、GF、VR、塔崩、沙林和VX的抗惊厥ED50分别为0.57、0.51、0.41、0.2、0.1和0.09mg/kg,而硫酸阿托品对梭曼、VR、塔崩、GF、沙林和VX的抗惊厥ED50分别为12.2、11.9、10.4、10.3、5.1和4.1mg/kg。在单独的实验中,接受2倍或5倍半数致死剂量梭曼攻击的动物,盐酸苯哌利多的抗惊厥ED50剂量分别为0.48(95%置信区间0.25 - 0.73)或0.57(95%置信区间0.38 - 0.84)mg/kg,而在这两种相同攻击条件下,阿托品(12.2mg/kg,肌肉注射)的抗惊厥ED50相同。本研究表明,所有神经毒剂都可引发癫痫持续状态,阿托品和苯哌利多的治疗效果大致与这些毒剂的致癫痫发作潜力平行。