Castel E, Benazet J, Trabelsi R, Laporte C, Samaha C, Saillant G
Service de Chirurgie Orthopédique et Traumatologique, Centre Hospitalo-Universitaire Paris VI, Pitié-Salpêtrière, 83, Bd de l'hôpital, 75013 Paris, France.
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 2000 Jun;86(4):381-9.
We analyzed calcaneum burst fractures in multiple trauma patients and propose a management scheme.
In a retrospective study, we isolated 23 patients with 31 calcaneum burst fractures. All were stage V in the Duparc classification. We call them "pied de mine" fractures as they resembled those described in military reports. Half of them (16 cases; 54%) were open fractures. All patients suffered multiple injuries and 12 had a psychiatric history. These fractures were associated with spinal fracture in 17 cases (73%) and half had neurologic deficit, limb fracture in 16 (73%), and pelvic fracture in 12 (52%). The most frequent associated foot injuries were a talus fracture in 9 cases (29%) and Chopart displacement in 10 cases (32%). Clinical evaluation used the Maryland foot score, foot print and radiologic evaluation with lateral retrotibial view.
Mean follow-up was 35 months. Mean Maryland foot score was 62.7 and 13 cases were pain free. Pain was due to conflict with the lateral malleolus, bony plantar thorns, medial malleolus and subtalar osteoarthritis. Orthopedic shoes were used 11 times. The other patients used sports shoes. Subtalar mobility was most frequently absent (23/29 cases, 2 amputations). Foot print showed 13/16 flat feet; 6 thorns were indirectly visible. Two patients had retraction toes and were initially treated by external fixation. Radiologic evaluation showed 23/29 complete subtalar arthrodeses, 23/29 migration of the great tuberosity, often(17/23 cases) associated with varus angulation. Eleven patients needed subsequent surgery: 5 for arthrodeses and 6 for resection of bony thorns. Rate of complication was high, especially for open fractures: 2 infections for 15 closed fractures, and 8 infections (50%) for 16 open fractures with 2 cases of chronic osteitis. Secondary amputation was required in 2/31 cases due to sepsis. TREATMENT PROPOSITIONS: For closed calcaneum burst fractures, it is better to wait one week before osteosynthesis. This delay is used to decrease edema with limb elevation and compressive bandaging. Skin tension due to trauma is increased by edema and osteosynthesis gives a high risk of wound disunion. We recommend reduction and Y-plate fixation even for burst fracture. Reduction must lower the tuberosity and correct the varus. After surgery, subtalar spontaneous arthrodesis is usually observed in a good position. Any bony plantar thorn must be resected. For open calcaneum burst fracture, the risk of sepsis is high. First treatment is debridement, stabilization and external fixation with antibiotic therapy. Stabilization should improve vascularization and facilitate internal fixation. The external fixation can be placed on the medial side to free the lateral approach to the calcaneum. Flap repair can be performed after one week when skin tension has subsided and areas of necrosis controlled.
我们分析了多发伤患者的跟骨爆裂骨折情况,并提出了一种治疗方案。
在一项回顾性研究中,我们选取了23例患者的31例跟骨爆裂骨折。所有骨折在迪帕克分类中均为V期。由于它们类似于军事报告中描述的骨折,我们将其称为“矿工足”骨折。其中一半(16例,54%)为开放性骨折。所有患者均有多发伤,12例有精神病史。这些骨折与脊柱骨折相关的有17例(73%),半数有神经功能缺损;与肢体骨折相关的有16例(73%),与骨盆骨折相关的有12例(52%)。最常见的相关足部损伤为距骨骨折9例(29%)和Chopart关节脱位10例(32%)。临床评估采用马里兰足部评分、脚印以及胫骨后外侧位X线评估。
平均随访35个月。平均马里兰足部评分为62.7分,13例无疼痛。疼痛原因包括与外踝冲突、足底骨棘、内踝以及距下骨关节炎。使用矫形鞋11次。其他患者穿运动鞋。距下关节活动度最常消失(23/29例,2例截肢)。脚印显示13/16为扁平足;6处骨棘间接可见。2例患者有足趾回缩,最初采用外固定治疗。X线评估显示23/29例距下关节完全融合,23/29例大结节移位,常(17/23例)伴有内翻成角。11例患者需要后续手术:5例进行关节融合,6例切除骨棘。并发症发生率较高,尤其是开放性骨折:15例闭合性骨折中有2例感染,16例开放性骨折中有8例感染(50%),2例慢性骨髓炎。31例中有2例因脓毒症需要二期截肢。
对于闭合性跟骨爆裂骨折,最好在骨固定前等待一周。这段时间用于通过抬高肢体和加压包扎减轻水肿。水肿会增加创伤导致的皮肤张力,骨固定会带来伤口裂开的高风险。即使是爆裂骨折,我们也建议进行复位和Y形钢板固定。复位必须降低结节并纠正内翻。术后,距下关节通常会在良好位置自发融合。任何足底骨棘都必须切除。对于开放性跟骨爆裂骨折,脓毒症风险较高。首要治疗是清创、稳定和外固定并给予抗生素治疗。稳定应改善血运并便于内固定。外固定可置于内侧,以腾出外侧入路处理跟骨。一周后,当皮肤张力消退且坏死区域得到控制时,可进行皮瓣修复。