Declau F, Cremers C, Van de Heyning P
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery and Communication Disorders, University of Antwerp, Edegem, Belgium.
Br J Audiol. 1999 Oct;33(5):313-27. doi: 10.3109/03005369909090115.
This consensus report represents a distillation of current opinion regarding diagnosis and management of congenital aural atresia. It also takes into account the philosophical differences which exist in Europe. Congenital aural atresia requires prompt diagnosis, genetic counselling and an early assessment of hearing. In bilateral atresia, early amplification with a bone conduction hearing aid is essential for proper speech development. Further rehabilitation in bilateral cases is managed with surgical reconstruction in selected patients or by implantation of a bone-anchored hearing aid. Atresia repair surgery is worthwhile if proper patient selection is made by use of stringent audiological and radiological criteria and state of the art surgery is performed. The divergent views concerning indications, ideal age for surgery and surgical approach to achieve better hearing are discussed. Review of the literature demonstrated that even in the hands of the best surgeons a mean hearing gain of only 20-25 dB is achieved in atresia Type II, with 30-35 dB in Type I. Therefore, surgical reconstruction should only be done in the more favourable cases where post-operative hearing of <25-30 dB is attainable. Less favoured patients should be helped with bone-anchored hearing aids, as this type of surgery does not interfere with the future use of new techniques.
本共识报告提炼了目前关于先天性耳道闭锁诊断与治疗的观点。它还考虑到了欧洲存在的理念差异。先天性耳道闭锁需要及时诊断、遗传咨询以及早期听力评估。对于双侧闭锁,早期使用骨导助听器进行听力放大对于正常言语发育至关重要。双侧病例的进一步康复治疗可通过为部分患者进行手术重建或植入骨锚式助听器来实现。如果通过严格的听力学和放射学标准进行恰当的患者选择,并采用先进的手术技术,耳道闭锁修复手术是值得的。文中讨论了关于手术适应症、理想手术年龄以及实现更好听力的手术方法等不同观点。文献综述表明,即使在最优秀的外科医生手中,II型闭锁术后平均听力增益仅为20 - 25分贝,I型为30 - 35分贝。因此,手术重建仅应在术后听力有望达到<25 - 30分贝的更有利病例中进行。不太适合手术的患者应使用骨锚式助听器,因为这类手术不会妨碍未来新技术的应用。