Courtay A, Couturon I, Charpentier E, Viens-Bitker C, Guillevin L, Etienne J P, Fery-Lemonnier E
Secrétariat Scientifique du Comité d'Evaluation et de Diffusion des Innovations Technologiques, Direction de la politique médicale AP-HP, Paris.
Ann Med Interne (Paris). 2000 May;151 Suppl 1:1S5-12.
In 1991 the public hospitals in Paris set up a plan to regulate the prescription of IVIg. The plan includes an expert committee and reliable data collection. The expert committee has a threefold mission: i) perform an annual up-date of IVIg classification using three categories: accepted indications (group I), currently deabated indications (group II), and unwarranted indications (group III); ii) develop guidelines for improved therapeutic strategies; iii) stimulate research. Data on use of IVIg are collected in 16 pilot hospitals. These data designate IVIg prescriptions by indication. Data are centralized by the CEDIT which publishes an annual report. Between 1988 and 1991, prescription of IVIg increased at an average annual rate of 33%. Between 1991 and 1996, the amount of IVIg used leveled off: approximately 330 kilograms/year, excluding research protocols. In 1997 there was a decline to 299 kilograms accounting for a total expenditure of 44 million French francs (US$ 6.7M). In 1997, group I prescriptions represented 80% of all IVIg prescriptions, group II 9.8% and group III 9.1%. Comparison of medical practice with a scientificaly recognised reference made it possible for AP-HP to set up an effective regulation of IVIg prescriptions. The longevity of this evaluation work is by itself a success.
1991年,巴黎的公立医院制定了一项计划来规范静脉注射免疫球蛋白(IVIg)的处方。该计划包括一个专家委员会和可靠的数据收集。专家委员会有三项任务:i)使用三类对IVIg分类进行年度更新:公认适应症(第一组)、当前有争议的适应症(第二组)和无正当理由的适应症(第三组);ii)制定改进治疗策略的指南;iii)推动研究。IVIg使用数据在16家试点医院收集。这些数据按适应症指定IVIg处方。数据由CEDIT集中,CEDIT发布年度报告。1988年至1991年期间,IVIg处方以年均33%的速度增长。1991年至1996年期间,IVIg的使用量趋于平稳:每年约330公斤,不包括研究方案。1997年降至299公斤,总支出为4400万法国法郎(670万美元)。1997年,第一组处方占所有IVIg处方的80%,第二组占9.8%,第三组占9.1%。将医疗实践与科学认可的参考标准进行比较,使巴黎公立医院集团(AP-HP)能够有效地规范IVIg处方。这项评估工作的持久性本身就是一项成功。