Coyne M J, Bonorris G G, Chung A, Goldstein L I, Lahana D, Schoenfield L J
N Engl J Med. 1975 Mar 20;292(12):604-7. doi: 10.1056/NEJM197503202921202.
In a controlled trial, 36 patients with asymptomatic radiolucent gallstones were treated with chenodeoxycholic acid, 750 mg per day, phenobarbital, 180 mg per day, combination of both drugs, and placebo. After one year, chenodeoxycholic acid, phenobarbital and the combination, but not placebo, significantly decreased biliary cholesterol saturation. The effect was significantly greater with chenodeoxycholic acid and the combination than with phenobarbital. Gallstones size decreased more than 50 per cent in nine of 20 patients receiving chenodeoxycholic acid, either alone or combined with phenobarbital, but in no patient receiving only phenobarbital or placebo. Gallstones disappeared completely in tow patients. Abnormalities in liver-function tests in thriee of 36 patients and in five of 16 liver biopsies, occured with equal frequency in the four treatment groups. Thus, after one year, phenobarbital alone was ineffective in gallstone dissolution. Chenodeoxycholic acid alone or combined with phenobarbital, however, offered a partially effective and safe treatment for asymptomatic radiolucent gallstones.
在一项对照试验中,36例无症状的透光性胆结石患者分别接受了每天750毫克鹅去氧胆酸、每天180毫克苯巴比妥、两种药物的联合治疗以及安慰剂治疗。一年后,鹅去氧胆酸、苯巴比妥及其联合用药组均显著降低了胆汁胆固醇饱和度,而安慰剂组则无此效果。鹅去氧胆酸及其联合用药组的效果明显优于苯巴比妥组。在接受鹅去氧胆酸单独治疗或与苯巴比妥联合治疗的20例患者中,有9例患者的胆结石尺寸缩小了50%以上,而仅接受苯巴比妥或安慰剂治疗的患者中则无此情况。有2例患者的胆结石完全消失。36例患者中有3例肝功能检查异常,16例肝活检中有5例出现异常,这在四个治疗组中的发生频率相同。因此,一年后,单独使用苯巴比妥对胆结石溶解无效。然而,鹅去氧胆酸单独使用或与苯巴比妥联合使用,为无症状的透光性胆结石提供了一种部分有效且安全的治疗方法。