Garr D R, Lackland D T, Wilson D B
Department of Family Medicine, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston 29425, USA.
Acad Med. 2000 Jul;75(7 Suppl):S14-21. doi: 10.1097/00001888-200007001-00003.
The Prevention Curriculum Assistance Program (PCAP) was initiated to help U.S. medical schools examine the extent to which they are evaluating the learning of medical students about disease prevention/health promotion. A survey was sent to all 144 allopathic and osteopathic medical schools, with an overall response rate of 68%. The results revealed more emphasis on teaching and evaluating the learning of medical students in the areas of clinical preventive services and quantitative methods, and less emphasis on the community dimensions of medical practice and health services organization and delivery. Written tests and unstructured observation are the most common methods of evaluation. Fewer than half of all respondents were satisfied with the quality of their assessment of student achievement in any of the four domains of prevention education. More than 30% expressed a desire to receive assistance with designing curricula and/ or evaluation methods in each of the four content areas examined. Several indicated their willingness to assist colleagues who want to improve their prevention curricula and/or measurement strategies. This study identified a need for more attention and support for prevention education and evaluation programs. Curriculum leaders can help by designating prevention a priority area and appointing faculty to be responsible for monitoring the content and quality of prevention teaching throughout the curriculum. Resources such as the Internet can be utilized to establish a network whereby medical schools can collaborate to improve their educational programs and evaluation methods in prevention.
预防课程援助项目(PCAP)旨在帮助美国医学院校审视其评估医学生疾病预防/健康促进学习情况的程度。向所有144所opathic和osteopathic医学院校发送了调查问卷,总体回复率为68%。结果显示,在临床预防服务和定量方法领域,对医学生学习的教学和评估更为重视,而对医疗实践的社区层面以及卫生服务组织与提供的重视程度较低。书面测试和非结构化观察是最常见的评估方法。在预防教育的四个领域中,不到一半的受访者对其学生成绩评估质量感到满意。超过30%的受访者表示希望在四个被考察的内容领域中的每个领域都能获得课程设计和/或评估方法方面的帮助。有几家表示愿意协助那些希望改进其预防课程和/或测量策略的同事。这项研究表明,需要对预防教育和评估项目给予更多关注和支持。课程负责人可以通过将预防指定为优先领域并任命教师负责在整个课程中监测预防教学的内容和质量来提供帮助。可以利用互联网等资源建立一个网络,医学院校可以通过该网络合作改进其预防教育项目和评估方法。