Hummers-Pradier E, Hinrichs I, Schroeter M, Kochen M M
Abteilung Allgemeinmedizin, Universität Göttingen.
Z Arztl Fortbild Qualitatssich. 2000 Jun;94(5):379-87.
Discrepancies between asthma management in general practice and national as well as international guidelines and recommendations are currently not fully explained. Subjective conceptions, ideas and beliefs are likely to be as important as factual knowledge when physicians decide how to treat their patients. Our study is part of the European Drug Education Project, an international project promoting rational pharmacotherapy in 5 European countries. Interviews on asthma and its treatment were conducted with 20 general practitioners in Germany, emphasizing beliefs and ideas on the disease and its origins as well as treatment goals and options rather than factual knowledge. Qualitative analysis was performed using a phenomenographic approach. Phenomenography aims at describing "subjective" reality, as it is conceived by people to understand learning and reflection processes. Even though most physicians know the treatment recommendations for asthma, adherence is variable. Reasons can be found in the variability of disease conceptions, often emphasizing psychosomatic or patient-centered aspects. The importance of individual treatment goals and experience of the doctor-patient relationship in a general practice setting is highlighted. Uneasiness concerning specialist recommendations on disease management and pharmacotherapy are commonly expressed. There are considerable variations in the physicians' conceptions on asthma and its management. Understanding these attitudes can provide a rational basis for the development of guidelines and implementation strategies corresponding to the needs of primary care physicians.
目前,普通医疗中哮喘管理与国家及国际指南和建议之间的差异尚未得到充分解释。当医生决定如何治疗患者时,主观观念、想法和信念可能与事实性知识同样重要。我们的研究是欧洲药物教育项目的一部分,该国际项目在5个欧洲国家推广合理药物治疗。我们对德国的20名全科医生进行了关于哮喘及其治疗的访谈,重点是对该疾病及其病因的信念和想法,以及治疗目标和选择,而非事实性知识。采用现象学方法进行定性分析。现象学旨在描述人们所构想的“主观”现实,以理解学习和反思过程。尽管大多数医生了解哮喘的治疗建议,但依从性存在差异。原因可能在于疾病观念的多样性,这种观念往往强调身心或以患者为中心的方面。突出了个体治疗目标以及全科医疗环境中医患关系经验的重要性。医生们普遍表达了对专科医生关于疾病管理和药物治疗建议的不安。医生们对哮喘及其管理的观念存在相当大的差异。理解这些态度可为制定符合基层医疗医生需求的指南和实施策略提供合理依据。