Fandiño-Franky J, Torres M, Nariño D, Fandiño J
Neurological Hospital, Colombian League Against Epilepsy, Cartagena.
Epilepsia. 2000;41 Suppl 4:S22-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1157.2000.tb01541.x.
The authors present the results of a series of corpus callosotomies (CCS) in 97 patients performed from 1989 to 1997 at the Hospital Neurologico of the Liga Colombiana Contra La Epilepsia, Cartagena, Colombia. This study demonstrates the feasibility of performing these procedures in the developing world and analyzes the outcome and cost of treatment. Patients with medically intractable secondarily generalized epilepsy, bilateral nonfocal epileptic electroencephalogram (EEG), and absence of progressive encephalopathy were accepted as candidates (patients aged 0-30 years; 62 children, 19 girls and 43 boys, with mean age at surgery of 7.9 years; 35 adults, 19 women and 16 men, with mean age at surgery of 25.8 years). Preoperatively, the mean seizure frequency was 12.1 per day, or 364 per month (range, 0.06-200 per day, 1.8-6000 per month). Before surgery, 40% of patients were classified with generalized tonic-clonic seizures of different etiologies, or cryptogenic seizures; 36% had mixed seizures; 19% had Lennox-Gastaut Syndrome; and 5% had West Syndrome. Usually, routine EEG, computed tomography, and clinical findings sufficed for the surgical decision. The standard microsurgical technique performed was an anterior two-thirds CCS by the same surgeon under general anesthesia. In five cases, an additional frontal lobe excision after electrocorticography and subdural electrode monitoring was carried out in the same session. The results were evaluated after a mean follow-up of 35 months (range, 12-28). Two thirds of patients became seizure-free or were left with none or some disabling seizures. AED medication was eased slightly after surgery. The complication rate was low. The patients underwent postoperative psychosocial studies and neuropsychological rehabilitation and showed tendencies toward improvement. The direct cost of CCS in U.S. dollars (US$) ranged between 3,137 and 3,995 depending on the preoperative studies. Thus, CCS is well suited for selected patients in developing countries. Thus far, implantation of a vagus nerve stimulator has exceeded our economic possibilities in treating similar patients. Some reflections on care and research among epilepsy patients in developing countries are discussed.
作者介绍了1989年至1997年在哥伦比亚卡塔赫纳哥伦比亚癫痫防治联盟神经医院对97例患者进行的一系列胼胝体切开术(CCS)的结果。本研究证明了在发展中国家开展这些手术的可行性,并分析了治疗结果和成本。患有药物难治性继发性全身性癫痫、双侧非局灶性癫痫脑电图(EEG)且无进行性脑病的患者被视为手术候选人(年龄0至30岁;62名儿童,19名女孩和43名男孩,手术平均年龄7.9岁;35名成年人,19名女性和16名男性,手术平均年龄25.8岁)。术前,平均癫痫发作频率为每天12.1次,即每月364次(范围为每天0.06至200次,每月1.8至6000次)。手术前,40%的患者被归类为不同病因的全身性强直阵挛发作或隐源性发作;36%有混合性发作;19%有Lennox-Gastaut综合征;5%有West综合征。通常,常规脑电图、计算机断层扫描和临床检查结果足以做出手术决定。所采用的标准显微手术技术是由同一位外科医生在全身麻醉下进行前三分之二胼胝体切开术。在5例病例中,在同一手术过程中,在皮层脑电图和硬膜下电极监测后进行了额外的额叶切除术。在平均随访35个月(范围12至28个月)后对结果进行评估。三分之二的患者癫痫发作停止,或仅遗留无残疾或有一些残疾的发作。术后抗癫痫药物治疗有所减轻。并发症发生率较低。患者接受了术后社会心理研究和神经心理康复,并有改善的趋势。CCS的直接成本以美元计算在3137至3995美元之间,具体取决于术前检查。因此,CCS非常适合发展中国家的特定患者。到目前为止,植入迷走神经刺激器超出了我们治疗类似患者的经济能力。文中还讨论了对发展中国家癫痫患者护理和研究的一些思考。