Carr D, Wilkinson K M, Blackman D, McIlvane W J
Welsh Centre for Learning Disabilities, Cardiff.
J Exp Anal Behav. 2000 Jul;74(1):101-14. doi: 10.1901/jeab.2000.74-101.
Studies from two different laboratories tested for equivalence classes in individuals with severe mental retardation and minimal verbal repertoires. In the first study, 3 individuals learned several matching-to-sample performances: matching picture comparison stimuli to dictated-word sample stimuli (AB), matching those same pictures to printed letter samples (CB), and also matching the pictures to nonrepresentative forms (DB). On subsequent tests, all individuals immediately displayed Emergent Relations AC, AD, BC, BD, CD, and DC, together constituting a positive demonstration of equivalence (as defined by Sidman). The second study obtained a positive equivalence test outcome in 1 of 2 individuals with similarly minimal verbal repertoires. Taken together, these studies call into question previous assertions that equivalence classes are demonstrable only in individuals with well-developed language repertoires.
来自两个不同实验室的研究对重度智力障碍且语言能力极其有限的个体进行了等价类测试。在第一项研究中,3名个体学习了几种样本匹配任务:将图片比较刺激与听写单词样本刺激进行匹配(AB),将相同图片与印刷字母样本进行匹配(CB),以及将图片与非代表性形式进行匹配(DB)。在随后的测试中,所有个体都立即表现出了新兴关系AC、AD、BC、BD、CD和DC,共同构成了等价性的积极证明(如Sidman所定义)。第二项研究在2名语言能力同样极其有限的个体中,有1人获得了等价性测试的阳性结果。综合来看,这些研究对之前认为等价类仅在语言能力发达的个体中才可证明的论断提出了质疑。