Lobley G E, Sinclair K D, Grant C M, Miller L, Mantle D, Calder A G, Warkup C C, Maltin C A
Rowett Research Institute, Bucksburn, Aberdeen, AB21 9SB, Scotland, UK.
Br J Nutr. 2000 Sep;84(3):275-84.
Eighteen pure-bred steers (live weight 350 kg) from each of two breeds, Aberdeen Angus (AA) and Charolais (CH), were split into three equal groups (six animals each) and offered three planes of nutrition during a 20-week period. The same ration formulation was offered to all animals with amounts adjusted at 3-week intervals to give predicted average weight gains of either 1.0 kg/d (M/M group) or 1.4 kg/d (H/H group). The remaining group (M/H) were offered the same amount of ration as the M/M group until 10 weeks before slaughter when the ration was increased to H. Data on animal performance, carcass characteristics and fibre-type composition in skeletal muscle are presented elsewhere (Maltin et al. 2000; Sinclair et al. 2000). On three occasions (17, 10 and 2 weeks before slaughter) the animals were transferred to metabolism stalls for 1 week, during which total urine collection for quantification of Ntau-methylhistidine (Ntau-MeH) elimination was performed for 4 d. On the last day, animals were infused for 11 h with [2H5]phenylalanine with frequent blood sampling (to allow determination of whole-body phenylalanine flux) followed by biopsies from m. longissimus lumborum and m. vastus lateralis to determine the fractional synthesis rate of mixed muscle protein. For both breeds, the absolute amount of Ntau-MeH eliminated increased with animal age or weight (P < 0.001) and was significantly greater for CH steers, at all intake comparisons, than for AA (P < 0.001). Estimates of fractional muscle breakdown rate (FBR; calculated from Ntau-MeH elimination and based on skeletal muscle as a fixed fraction of live weight) showed an age (or weight) decline for M/M and H/H groups of both breeds (P < 0.001). FBR was greater for the H/H group (P = 0.044). The M/H group also showed a lower FBR for the first two measurement periods (both at M intake) but increased when intake was raised to H. When allowance was made for differences in lean content (calculated from fat scores and eye muscle area in carcasses at the end of period 3), there were significant differences in muscle FBR with intake (P = 0.012) but not between breed. Whole-body protein flux (WBPF; g/d) based on plasma phenylalanine kinetics increased with age or weight (P < 0.001) and was similar between breeds. The WBPF was lower for M/M compared with H/H (P < 0.001) based on either total or per kg live weight0.75. Muscle protein fractional synthesis rate (FSR) declined with age for both breeds and tended to be higher at H/H compared with M intakes (intake x period effects, P < 0.05). Changing intake from M to H caused a significant increase (P < 0.001) in FSR. The FSR values for AA were significantly greater than for CH at comparable ages (P = 0. 044). Although FSR and FBR responded to nutrition, these changes in protein metabolism were not reflected in differences in meat eating quality (Sinclair et al. 2000).
选取阿伯丁安格斯牛(AA)和夏洛来牛(CH)两个品种的18头纯种阉牛(活重350千克),每个品种的牛均分为三组(每组6头),在20周的时间内给予三种营养水平。所有动物都采用相同的日粮配方,每隔3周调整日粮量,以使预计平均日增重分别达到1.0千克/天(M/M组)或1.4千克/天(H/H组)。其余一组(M/H)在屠宰前10周之前给予与M/M组相同量的日粮,之后日粮增加至H水平。动物生长性能、胴体特征以及骨骼肌纤维类型组成的数据已在其他文献中发表(Maltin等,2000;Sinclair等,2000)。在三个时间点(屠宰前17周、10周和2周),将动物转移至代谢栏中饲养1周,在此期间进行为期4天的总尿液收集,以定量测定Nτ-甲基组氨酸(Ntau-MeH)的排泄量。在最后一天,给动物静脉注射[2H5]苯丙氨酸11小时,并频繁采集血液样本(以测定全身苯丙氨酸通量),随后从腰大肌和股外侧肌采集活检样本,以测定混合肌肉蛋白的分数合成率。对于两个品种,Ntau-MeH的排泄绝对量均随动物年龄或体重增加而增加(P<0.001),并且在所有采食量比较中,CH阉牛的排泄量均显著高于AA阉牛(P<0.001)。肌肉分解率(FBR;根据Ntau-MeH排泄量计算,并以骨骼肌占活重的固定比例为基础)的估计值显示,两个品种的M/M组和H/H组的FBR均随年龄(或体重)下降(P<0.001)。H/H组的FBR更高(P=0.044)。M/H组在前两个测量期(均为M采食量时)的FBR也较低,但采食量提高到H水平时FBR增加。考虑到瘦肉含量的差异(根据第3期结束时胴体的脂肪评分和眼肌面积计算),肌肉FBR随采食量有显著差异(P=0.012),但品种间无显著差异。基于血浆苯丙氨酸动力学的全身蛋白通量(WBPF;克/天)随年龄或体重增加(P<0.001),且品种间相似。基于总采食量或每千克活重0.75计算,M/M组的WBPF低于H/H组(P<0.001)。两个品种的肌肉蛋白分数合成率(FSR)均随年龄下降,且在H/H采食量时往往高于M采食量时(采食量×时期效应,P<0.05)。采食量从M增加到H会导致FSR显著增加(P<0.001)。在可比年龄时,AA的FSR值显著高于CH(P=0.044)。尽管FSR和FBR对营养有反应,但蛋白质代谢的这些变化并未在肉的食用品质差异中体现出来(Sinclair等,2000)。