Gmür H, Scherrer M
Schweiz Med Wochenschr. 1979 Jun 9;109(23):881-4.
16 cooperative asthmatic patients with exercise-induced asthma (with more than 15% decrease in FEV1 after strenuous work on a treadmill with 10% upward; pulse rates over 180 per minute during the work-phase) were selected to take part in a double-blind crossover trial. The 8 women and 8 men, with ages ranging from 15 to 57 years (mean 25) underwent 4 exercise tests. The effects on exercise-induced asthma of 20 mg disodium cromoglycate (DSCG) inhaled with a spinhaler 30 minutes before exercise were compared to 2 mg of ketotifen taken orally 3 hours before exercise, and likewise DSCG was compared to a placebo powder inhaled with a spinhaler, and ketotifen with placebo tablets. The whole study lasted from January to March. Ten minutes after exercise the following changes in FEV1 (in percent of control value measured before exercise) were seen: after inhalation of a placebo powder the FEV1 decreased to 66% with an almost equal decrease after taking placebo tablets (67%) (0.45 greater than p greater than 0.40) whereas, in comparison, the decrease in FEV1 after DSCG (84%) is smaller than that after inhalation of a placebo powder (66%) (p less than 0.0025). In contrast to these results was the equal decrease in FEV1 after ketotifen (70%) (0.35 greater than p greater than 0.30) and placebo tablets (67%). Although a relatively high chosen dosage of ketotifen was given, it does not seem capable of inhibiting mediator release from the bronchial mast-cells as DSCG does. It is concluded that ketotifen given orally 3 hours before the exercise test is not effective against exercise-induced asthma.
选取16例运动诱发性哮喘的合作患者(在倾斜10%的跑步机上剧烈运动后第一秒用力呼气量(FEV1)下降超过15%;运动阶段心率超过每分钟180次)参与一项双盲交叉试验。8名女性和8名男性,年龄在15至57岁之间(平均25岁),接受了4次运动测试。将运动前30分钟用旋转吸入器吸入20毫克色甘酸钠(DSCG)对运动诱发性哮喘的效果,与运动前3小时口服2毫克酮替芬的效果进行比较,同样将DSCG与用旋转吸入器吸入的安慰剂粉末进行比较,将酮替芬与安慰剂片剂进行比较。整个研究从1月持续到3月。运动后10分钟,观察到FEV1(以运动前测量的对照值的百分比表示)有以下变化:吸入安慰剂粉末后FEV1降至66%,服用安慰剂片剂后下降几乎相同(67%)(0.45>p>0.40),而相比之下,DSCG后FEV1的下降(84%)小于吸入安慰剂粉末后的下降(66%)(p<0.0025)。与这些结果相反的是酮替芬(70%)(0.35>p>0.30)和安慰剂片剂(67%)后FEV1下降相同。尽管给予了相对较高剂量选择的酮替芬,但它似乎不像DSCG那样能够抑制支气管肥大细胞释放介质。得出的结论是,运动测试前3小时口服酮替芬对运动诱发性哮喘无效。