Cox I D, Clague J R, Bagger J P, Ward D E, Kaski J C
Cardiological Sciences Department, St. George's Hospital Medical School, London, U.K.
Clin Cardiol. 2000 Sep;23(9):645-52. doi: 10.1002/clc.4960230904.
Patients with chest pain and normal coronary arteriograms (CPNA) may present with unstable symptoms and other evidence of ischemia during clinical follow-up. Although repeat angiography usually proves negative, functional assessment of coronary vasomotor abnormalities may provide additional pathophysiologic information.
The study was undertaken to evaluate the relationship between endothelial dysfunction and subangiographic atheroma in patients with CPNA undergoing repeat angiography because of unstable symptoms.
We investigated nine patients with CPNA (8 women, mean age 57 +/- 9 years) undergoing repeat angiography because of unstable anginal symptoms. After normal angiography, simultaneous coronary epicardial and microvascular vasomotor responses to intracoronary vasodilators [acetylcholine (10(-6) M), adenosine (18 micrograms) and nitroglycerin (300 micrograms)] were investigated in the left anterior descending artery using quantitative angiography and Doppler flow measurements. The presence of subangiographic atheroma was assessed by intravascular ultrasound.
Three patients demonstrated proximal and distal epicardial vasoconstriction and a reduction in coronary flow in response to acetylcholine, indicating concordant epicardial and microvascular endothelial dysfunction. These changes were associated with chest pain and ischemic electrocardiographic changes in two patients. None of the remaining patients suffered chest pain in response to intracoronary acetylcholine. Six patients had significant subangiographic disease (intimal thickness > 0.3 mm) on intravascular ultrasound imaging, and multivariate analysis indicated a significant relationship (R2 = 0.89, overall p = 0.001) between the extent of subangiographic disease and both plasma cholesterol concentration and hypertensive history. No significant relationship was demonstrated between endothelial dysfunction and the extent of subangiographic disease.
Concordant epicardial and microvascular endothelial dysfunction may be pathophysiologically and clinically significant in unstable patients with CPNA but does not appear to be directly related to the extent of subangiographic atheroma.
胸痛且冠状动脉造影正常(CPNA)的患者在临床随访期间可能出现不稳定症状及其他缺血证据。尽管重复血管造影通常结果为阴性,但对冠状动脉血管舒缩异常的功能评估可能会提供额外的病理生理信息。
本研究旨在评估因症状不稳定而接受重复血管造影的CPNA患者中内皮功能障碍与亚血管造影性动脉粥样硬化之间的关系。
我们调查了9例因不稳定型心绞痛症状而接受重复血管造影的CPNA患者(8名女性,平均年龄57±9岁)。血管造影正常后,使用定量血管造影和多普勒血流测量法,在左前降支中研究冠状动脉心外膜和微血管对冠状动脉血管扩张剂[乙酰胆碱(10⁻⁶M)、腺苷(18微克)和硝酸甘油(300微克)]的同时血管舒缩反应。通过血管内超声评估亚血管造影性动脉粥样硬化的存在情况。
3例患者表现出近端和远端心外膜血管收缩以及冠状动脉血流减少,对乙酰胆碱有反应,表明心外膜和微血管内皮功能障碍一致。这些变化与2例患者的胸痛和缺血性心电图改变相关。其余患者中无一例因冠状动脉内注射乙酰胆碱而出现胸痛。6例患者在血管内超声成像上有明显的亚血管造影性病变(内膜厚度>0.3毫米),多变量分析表明亚血管造影性病变程度与血浆胆固醇浓度和高血压病史之间存在显著关系(R² = 0.89,总体p = 0.001)。内皮功能障碍与亚血管造影性病变程度之间未显示出显著关系。
心外膜和微血管内皮功能障碍一致在不稳定的CPNA患者中可能在病理生理和临床上具有重要意义,但似乎与亚血管造影性动脉粥样硬化的程度无直接关系。