Charen J, Taves D R, Stamm J W, Parkins F M
Calcif Tissue Int. 1979 Apr 17;27(2):95-9. doi: 10.1007/BF02441168.
Recently published bone fluoride values from Iowa are very high compared to earlier reports, suggesting an increase in fluoride intake. Reanalysis of the Iowa specimens shows levels one-fourth those reported by the Iowa laboratory indicating an error in the original report. Seventeen bone specimens, collected from long-term residents of Rochester, New York, drinking 1 ppm F- water, had a mean value of 2085 +/- 270 ppm F- on an ashed-weight basis. This value is not significantly different from that predicted by the data of Zipkin et al. in 1958. These data, therefore, do not support the contention that there has been an increase in fluoride intake.
与早期报告相比，最近公布的爱荷华州骨骼氟含量值非常高，这表明氟摄入量有所增加。对爱荷华州标本的重新分析显示，其含量仅为该州实验室报告值的四分之一，这表明原始报告存在错误。从纽约罗切斯特长期居民中收集的17份骨骼标本，这些居民饮用含1 ppm氟化物的水，以灰重计，其平均氟含量值为2085 +/- 270 ppm。该值与齐普金等人1958年的数据预测值没有显著差异。因此，这些数据并不支持氟摄入量增加这一论点。
