Weiss S J, Ernst A A, Phillips J, Hill B
University of California Davis Medical Center, Sacramento, USA.
Am J Emerg Med. 2000 Oct;18(6):666-70. doi: 10.1053/ajem.2000.16299.
There are gender differences in emergency medical services (EMS) transports and management based on diagnosis. Data were extracted from the EMS State Ambulance Transport database. This database exists because of a legal requirement that all EMS transports generated by 911 calls and all interhospital transports be reported to the State EMS Bureau. All ambulance transports reported to the State EMS Division during 1995 were evaluated. Cases were excluded if they were aborted, admission or discharge transports, outpatient transports, or cases listed as "other" without a diagnosis. Gender-related treatment differences were determined for problems for which EMTs have specific treatment options. These were cardiac arrest, chest pain, allergic reactions, and extremity fractures. Results were compared using a two-tailed Chi squared or Fischer's Exact with significance at P < .05. Odds Ratios (OR) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were calculated. There were a total of 164,595 ambulance transports reported to the State EMS Division. Of these 76,074 (46%) were men and 88,521 (54%) were women. Of these, 50,211 were excluded. This left 52,607 injury transport and 61,777 illnesses transport. Men were significantly more likely than women to have injuries related to all-terrain vehicle accidents, motorcycle accidents, RV accidents, burns, gunshot wounds, and stab wounds. Men were significantly more likely than women to have illnesses related to cardiac arrest, dead on arrivals (DOAs), drowning, and smoke inhalation. For cardiac arrest transports, significantly more male patients presented ventricular fibrillation, more males received defibrillation, lidocaine, and bicarbonate, but more women received atropine. Male chest pain patients were more likely to receive oxygen and morphine and less likely to receive nitroglycerin. Male allergic reaction patients were more likely to receive an i.v. and subcutaneous epinephrine. Male extremity fracture patients were more likely to get an i.v. line, but there was no difference in morphine use or splinting. There are numerous disease-specific gender differences in the demographics of illness and injury transported by EMS. The use of various medications and procedures may also be related to gender. Understanding these differences may help in preparing EMS professionals for patient management.
基于诊断结果,紧急医疗服务(EMS)在转运和管理方面存在性别差异。数据取自EMS国家救护车转运数据库。该数据库的存在是因为法律要求,所有由911呼叫产生的EMS转运以及所有医院间转运都要上报给州EMS局。对1995年期间上报给州EMS部门的所有救护车转运情况进行了评估。如果病例属于中途放弃、入院或出院转运、门诊转运,或者列为“其他”且无诊断结果,则予以排除。针对急救人员有特定治疗方案的问题,确定了与性别相关的治疗差异。这些问题包括心脏骤停、胸痛、过敏反应和四肢骨折。使用双侧卡方检验或费舍尔精确检验进行结果比较,显著性水平为P <.05。计算了比值比(OR)和95%置信区间(CI)。上报给州EMS部门的救护车转运病例共有164,595例。其中,76,074例(46%)为男性,88,521例(54%)为女性。其中,50,211例被排除。剩余52,607例为受伤转运病例和61,777例为疾病转运病例。男性比女性更有可能遭遇与全地形车事故、摩托车事故、房车事故、烧伤、枪伤和刺伤相关的伤害。男性比女性更有可能患有与心脏骤停、到达时死亡(DOA)、溺水和吸入烟雾相关的疾病。对于心脏骤停转运病例,男性患者出现心室颤动的比例显著更高,更多男性接受了除颤、利多卡因和碳酸氢盐治疗,但更多女性接受了阿托品治疗。男性胸痛患者更有可能接受氧气和吗啡治疗,而接受硝酸甘油治疗的可能性较小。男性过敏反应患者更有可能接受静脉注射和皮下注射肾上腺素治疗。男性四肢骨折患者更有可能接受静脉输液,但在吗啡使用或夹板固定方面没有差异。在EMS转运的疾病和伤害人群中,存在许多特定疾病的性别差异。各种药物和治疗程序的使用也可能与性别有关。了解这些差异可能有助于让EMS专业人员做好患者管理的准备。