Arbizu T, Alvarez-Cermeño J C, Decap G, Fernández O, Uría D F, García Merino A, Izquierdo G, Montalbán X
Unidad de Esclerosis Multiple, Hospital de Belivitge, Barcelona, Spain.
Acta Neurol Scand. 2000 Oct;102(4):209-17. doi: 10.1034/j.1600-0404.2000.102004209.x.
A protocol system is being used in Spain for the prescription of innovative drugs including interferon beta-1b (IFNbeta-1b). Petitions for dispensing and reimbursement are based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria of pivotal trials, and are reviewed individually for approval by specialist committees. To estimate the performance of IFNbeta-1b in the clinical setting, data collected by the INSALUD and regional health services of Andalusia and Catalonia, together responsible for the healthcare of nearly 30 million individuals, were compiled in a common database for analysis.
Data comprise demographic and disease characteristics at the time of petition and at follow-up 3 months after treatment initiation and every 6 months thereafter. Efficacy was estimated by mean number of relapses per year, proportion of relapse-free patients, and disease progression as measured by the Expanded Disability Status Scale (EDSS). Safety parameters included adverse events and laboratory analyses.
Between September 1995 and database cutoff in mid-1998, petitions of 1419 patients were approved for IFNbeta-1b treatment. Patients were homogenous across the three databases and in the subgroups of patients completing 1 year (n = 940) and 2 years (n = 302) of treatment. There was a marked decrease in the mean number of relapses in the first 12 months of IFNbeta-1b treatment for the 938 patients documented for 12 months, with a mean of 0.4 (+/- 0.7 SD) relapses per patient and year, and a 2-year mean of 0.9 (+/- 1.20 SD) in the 302 patients documented for 24 months. Of the 938 patients followed for > or = 12 months, 505 (53.8%) were documented as being relapse-free during 12 months of treatment, and 146 (48.3%) of the 302 patients followed for > or = 24 months, were relapse-free during 24 months of treatment. There were no differences in mean or median EDSS scores between baseline and months 12 and 24. Skin disorders were the most frequent adverse events, reported in over one-third of all patients; there were 159 injection site events, most frequently erythema (115 events). Systemic AEs pointing towards flu-like symptoms were reported in 288 of 1419 patients (20.3%). Leukopenia was the most frequently reported laboratory event. Elevations in liver transaminases were noted for 12 patients (0.8%) with SGOT increase and 7 (0.5%) with SGPT increase.
The protocol system has helped make IFN treatment available to 8-10% of the estimated 15,000-18,000 MS patients in the regions studied. In terms of efficacy, IFNbeta-1b performed in line with the pivotal study results. The safety profile of IFNbeta-1b was consistent with the published findings and the drug labelling, and no new side effects or increased incidence of known side effects was observed.
西班牙正在使用一种方案系统来开具包括干扰素β-1b(IFNβ-1b)在内的创新药物处方。配药和报销申请基于关键试验的纳入和排除标准,并由专家委员会进行单独审查以批准。为评估IFNβ-1b在临床环境中的表现,由负责近3000万人医疗保健的西班牙国家卫生系统(INSALUD)以及安达卢西亚和加泰罗尼亚的地区卫生服务机构收集的数据,被汇总到一个公共数据库中进行分析。
数据包括申请时以及治疗开始后3个月随访时和此后每6个月随访时的人口统计学和疾病特征。疗效通过每年复发平均次数、无复发患者比例以及通过扩展残疾状态量表(EDSS)测量的疾病进展来评估。安全参数包括不良事件和实验室分析。
在1995年9月至1998年年中数据库截止期间,1419例患者的IFNβ-1b治疗申请获得批准。三个数据库中的患者以及完成1年(n = 940)和2年(n = 302)治疗的患者亚组具有同质性。在记录了12个月的938例患者中,IFNβ-1b治疗的前12个月复发平均次数显著减少,每位患者每年平均复发0.4次(±0.7标准差),在记录了24个月的302例患者中,2年平均复发0.9次(±1.20标准差)。在随访≥12个月的938例患者中,505例(53.8%)在治疗的12个月期间记录为无复发,在随访≥24个月的302例患者中,146例(48.3%)在治疗的24个月期间无复发。基线与12个月和24个月时的EDSS平均或中位数评分无差异。皮肤疾病是最常见的不良事件,超过三分之一的患者报告有此类事件;有159例注射部位事件,最常见的是红斑(115例)。在1419例患者中有288例(20.3%)报告有类似流感症状的全身性不良事件。白细胞减少是最常报告的实验室事件。12例患者(0.8%)的谷草转氨酶(SGOT)升高,7例患者(0.5%)的谷丙转氨酶(SGPT)升高。
该方案系统有助于使IFN治疗应用于所研究地区估计15000 - 18000例多发性硬化症患者中的8 - 10%。在疗效方面,IFNβ-1b的表现与关键研究结果一致。IFNβ-1b的安全性概况与已发表的研究结果和药品标签一致,未观察到新的副作用或已知副作用发生率增加。