Arpino C, Brescianini S, Robert E, Castilla E E, Cocchi G, Cornel M C, de Vigan C, Lancaster P A, Merlob P, Sumiyoshi Y, Zampino G, Renzi C, Rosano A, Mastroiacovo P
International Centre for Birth Defects, Rome, Italy.
Epilepsia. 2000 Nov;41(11):1436-43. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1157.2000.tb00119.x.
The study goal was to assess teratogenic effects of antiepileptic drugs (AEDs) through the use of a surveillance system (MADRE) of infants with malformations.
Information on all malformed infants (1990-1996) with maternal first-trimester drug exposure was collected by the International Clearinghouse for Birth Defects and Monitoring Systems (ICBDMS). Cases were defined as infants presenting with a specific malformation, and controls were defined as infants presenting with any other birth defect. Exposure was defined by the use of AEDs during the first trimester of pregnancy. The association of AEDs with malformations was then estimated by calculating the odds ratios with 95% confidence intervals and testing their homogeneity among registries.
Among 8005 cases of malformations, 299 infants were exposed in utero to AEDs. Of those exposed to monotherapy, 65 were exposed to phenobarbital, 10 to methylphenobarbital, 80 to valproic acid, 46 to carbamazepine, 24 to phenytoin, and 16 to other AEDs. Associations were found for spina bifida with valproic acid. Infants exposed to phenobarbital and to methylphenobarbital showed an increased risk of oral clefts. Cardiac malformations were found to be associated with phenobarbital, methylphenobarbital, valproic acid, and carbamazepine. Hypospadias was associated with valproic acid. Porencephaly and other specified anomalies of brain, anomalies of face, coarctation of aorta, and limb reduction defects were found to be associated with valproic acid.
Using the MADRE system, we confirmed known teratogenic effects of AEDs. We also found increased risks for malformations that had never been reported associated with AEDs or for which the association was suggested by case reports.
本研究的目标是通过使用一个针对畸形婴儿的监测系统(MADRE)来评估抗癫痫药物(AEDs)的致畸作用。
国际出生缺陷信息交换中心和监测系统(ICBDMS)收集了所有1990年至1996年孕早期母亲有药物暴露史的畸形婴儿的信息。病例定义为患有特定畸形的婴儿,对照定义为患有任何其他出生缺陷的婴儿。暴露定义为孕期头三个月使用AEDs。然后通过计算比值比及其95%置信区间并检验各登记处之间的同质性来估计AEDs与畸形之间的关联。
在8005例畸形病例中,有299例婴儿在子宫内暴露于AEDs。在接受单一疗法的暴露者中,65例暴露于苯巴比妥,10例暴露于甲基苯巴比妥,80例暴露于丙戊酸,46例暴露于卡马西平,24例暴露于苯妥英,16例暴露于其他AEDs。发现脊柱裂与丙戊酸有关。暴露于苯巴比妥和甲基苯巴比妥的婴儿出现唇腭裂的风险增加。发现心脏畸形与苯巴比妥、甲基苯巴比妥、丙戊酸和卡马西平有关。尿道下裂与丙戊酸有关。脑穿通畸形和其他特定的脑异常、面部异常、主动脉缩窄和肢体减少缺陷与丙戊酸有关。
使用MADRE系统,我们证实了AEDs已知的致畸作用。我们还发现了一些畸形风险增加的情况,这些畸形从未被报道与AEDs有关,或者病例报告曾提示存在关联。