Grimes A L, McCullough L B, Kunik M E, Molinari V, Workman R H
Department of Psychiatry, University of California, San Diego, CA, USA.
Psychiatr Serv. 2000 Dec;51(12):1561-7. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.51.12.1561.
The authors examine the less-studied components of patients' autonomous decision making, or decisional autonomy, in the light of current research in psychiatry and neuropsychology and developments in the construct of informed consent. The three components of decisional autonomy-understanding, intentionality, and noncontrol or voluntariness-are related to clinical constructs in psychiatry and neuropsychology, in particular to executive control functions. The authors review studies that examine deficits in prefrontal cerebral function in schizophrenia, depression, and some anxiety disorders that are related to intentionality and voluntariness. Assessment of decisional autonomy should encompass evaluation of impaired intentionality and voluntariness, not simply impaired understanding. The main response to finding such impairments should be to provide treatment to ameliorate them. New strategies for psychiatric care should be developed to address the clinical challenges of an increasingly complex view of decisional autonomy.
作者依据当前精神病学和神经心理学研究以及知情同意概念的发展,审视了患者自主决策(即决策自主性)中较少被研究的组成部分。决策自主性的三个组成部分——理解、意向性以及无控制或自愿性——与精神病学和神经心理学中的临床概念相关,尤其与执行控制功能相关。作者回顾了一些研究,这些研究考察了精神分裂症、抑郁症和某些焦虑症中前额叶脑功能缺陷与意向性和自愿性的关系。对决策自主性的评估应包括对受损的意向性和自愿性的评估,而不仅仅是受损的理解。发现此类损伤后的主要应对措施应是提供治疗以改善它们。应制定新的精神科护理策略,以应对决策自主性这一日益复杂观点所带来的临床挑战。