Kalis C H, Hesselink J W, Barkema H W, Collins M T
Department of Ruminant Health, Animal Health Service, Drachten, The Netherlands.
J Vet Diagn Invest. 2000 Nov;12(6):547-51. doi: 10.1177/104063870001200609.
Fecal samples from 733 cows in 11 dairy herds with a low prevalence of paratuberculosis were cultured for the presence of Mycobacterium avium subsp. paratuberculosis both individually and after combining (pooling) in groups of 5. The culture procedure was the modified Jorgensen method, which uses NaOH and oxalic acid for decontamination and modified Lowenstein-Jensen agar slants for cultivation. Pooling was performed by mixing fecal samples from 5 animals ordered by age, herein referred to as strategic pooling. Culture of individual fecal samples detected M. a. paratuberculosis infections in 43 of the 733 cows and 7 of 11 infected herds (herd sensitivity = 64%). Culture of pooled fecal samples detected M. a. paratuberculosis in 28 of 151 pooled samples representing 8 of the infected 11 herds (herd sensitivity = 73%). Feces of the 43 culture-positive cows was included in 32 pools: of these 32 pools, 26 were culture positive and 6 were culture negative. In addition to the 26 positive pools containing feces from cows that were found culture positive on individual fecal samples, another 2 pools were culture positive, although comprised of feces from cows with negative results after culture of individual fecal samples. From the total of 45 infected cows that were found (43 by individual fecal culture and an additional 2 by pooled fecal culture), individual fecal culture detected 43 of these 45 (96%), while pooled fecal culture detected 39 (87%). Culture of strategically pooled fecal samples using the modified Jorgensen method was equivalent in herd sensitivity to the culture of individual fecal samples and is significantly less expensive.
对11个副结核病低流行率的奶牛场中733头奶牛的粪便样本进行培养,以检测副结核分枝杆菌亚种副结核分枝杆菌的存在,样本既单独培养,也按5头一组合并后培养。培养程序采用改良的约根森方法,该方法使用氢氧化钠和草酸进行去污,并使用改良的罗 - 琴氏琼脂斜面进行培养。合并样本的操作是将按年龄排序的5头动物的粪便样本混合,在此称为策略性合并。对单个粪便样本进行培养,在733头奶牛中有43头检测到副结核分枝杆菌感染,在11个受感染的牛群中有7个检测到感染(牛群敏感性 = 64%)。对合并粪便样本进行培养,在代表11个受感染牛群中8个的151个合并样本中有28个检测到副结核分枝杆菌(牛群敏感性 = 73%)。43头培养阳性奶牛的粪便被纳入32个合并样本组:在这32个合并样本组中,26个培养阳性,6个培养阴性。除了26个含有个体粪便样本培养呈阳性的奶牛粪便的阳性合并样本组外,另有2个合并样本组培养呈阳性,尽管它们由个体粪便样本培养结果为阴性的奶牛粪便组成。在总共发现的45头受感染奶牛中(43头通过个体粪便培养发现,另外2头通过合并粪便培养发现),个体粪便培养检测到其中43头(96%),而合并粪便培养检测到39头(87%)。使用改良约根森方法对策略性合并粪便样本进行培养,在牛群敏感性方面与个体粪便样本培养相当,且成本显著更低。