Ingersoll G L, McIntosh E, Williams M
Director of Clinical Nursing Research, Strong Memorial Hospital, Rochester, New York, USA.
J Adv Nurs. 2000 Nov;32(5):1272-81. doi: 10.1046/j.1365-2648.2000.01598.x.
Advanced practice nurses (APNs) in the USA are registered nurses who hold masters or doctoral degrees in a specialized area of nursing. They provide advanced clinical care to clients, manage health care systems and influence health care decision-making through expert clinical reasoning and research and theory-based action. APN impact on health care outcomes is supported by studies using physician-focused indicators, although a few studies have identified several that are sensitive to or reflective of advanced practice nursing. A modified Delphi survey was conducted during May 1997-December 1998 to determine the outcome indicators APNs recommend for use in measuring their effect on care delivery outcomes. A convenience sample of 66 APNs attending a statewide outcomes conference identified 27 potential outcome indicators. These indicators were included in a mailed survey sent to APNs working in Tennessee. Respondents were asked to rate each indicator for validity, sensitivity, feasibility, utility and cost. In the second round of the survey, they were asked whether or not they agreed with the rank ordering of indicators, which was determined by the means calculated from responses in the first round. The 10 highest ranked indicators were satisfaction with care delivery, symptom resolution/reduction, perception of being well cared for, compliance/adherence with treatment plan, knowledge of patients and families, trust of care provider, collaboration among care providers, frequency and type of procedures ordered and quality of life. APNs identified both direct and indirect measures of effect on care delivery outcomes. Some of these are currently used as indicators of advanced practice, but many are not. Additional research is needed to determine whether the indicators proposed are valid and sensitive to advanced practice care by nurses.
美国的高级执业护士(APNs)是在护理专业领域拥有硕士或博士学位的注册护士。他们为客户提供高级临床护理,管理医疗保健系统,并通过专业的临床推理、研究以及基于理论的行动来影响医疗保健决策。尽管有一些研究已经确定了一些对高级实践护理敏感或能反映其情况的指标,但使用以医生为重点的指标进行的研究支持了APNs对医疗保健结果的影响。在1997年5月至1998年12月期间进行了一项改良的德尔菲调查,以确定APNs建议用于衡量其对护理服务结果影响的结果指标。一个由66名参加全州范围结果会议的APNs组成的便利样本确定了27个潜在的结果指标。这些指标被纳入了一项邮寄给在田纳西州工作的APNs的调查中。受访者被要求对每个指标的有效性、敏感性、可行性、实用性和成本进行评分。在第二轮调查中,他们被问及是否同意指标的排序,该排序是由第一轮调查的回复计算得出的平均值确定的。排名最高的10个指标是对护理服务的满意度、症状缓解/减轻、对得到良好护理的感知、对治疗计划的依从性/坚持性、对患者及其家庭的了解、对护理提供者的信任、护理提供者之间的协作、所开医嘱的频率和类型以及生活质量。APNs确定了对护理服务结果影响的直接和间接衡量指标。其中一些目前被用作高级实践的指标,但许多并非如此。需要进行更多研究以确定所提出的指标对于护士的高级实践护理是否有效和敏感。