Clarke R W, Coull B, Reinisch U, Catalano P, Killingsworth C R, Koutrakis P, Kavouras I, Murthy G G, Lawrence J, Lovett E, Wolfson J M, Verrier R L, Godleski J J
Department of Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
Environ Health Perspect. 2000 Dec;108(12):1179-87. doi: 10.1289/ehp.001081179.
Pulmonary inflammatory and hematologic responses of canines were studied after exposure to concentrated ambient particles (CAPs) using the Harvard ambient particle concentrator (HAPC). For pulmonary inflammatory studies, normal dogs were exposed in pairs to either CAPs or filtered air (paired studies) for 6 hr/day on 3 consecutive days. For hematologic studies, dogs were exposed for 6 hr/day for 3 consecutive days with one receiving CAPs while the other was simultaneously exposed to filtered air; crossover of exposure took place the following week (crossover studies). Physicochemical characterization of CAPs exposure samples included measurements of particle mass, size distribution, and composition. No statistical differences in biologic responses were found when all CAPs and all sham exposures were compared. However, the variability in biologic response was considerably higher with CAPs exposure. Subsequent exploratory graphical analyses and mixed linear regression analyses suggested associations between CAPs constituents and biologic responses. Factor analysis was applied to the compositional data from paired and crossover experiments to determine elements consistently associated with each other in CAPs samples. In paired experiments, four factors were identified; in crossover studies, a total of six factors were observed. Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) and hematologic data were regressed on the factor scores. Increased BAL neutrophil percentage, total peripheral white blood cell (WBC) counts, circulating neutrophils, and circulating lymphocytes were associated with increases in the aluminum/silicon factor. Increased circulating neutrophils and increased BAL macrophages were associated with the vanadium/nickel factor. Increased BAL neutrophils were associated with the bromine/lead factor when only the compositional data from the third day of CAPs exposure were used. Significant decreases in red blood cell counts and hemoglobin levels were correlated with the sulfur factor. BAL or hematologic parameters were not associated with increases in total CAPs mass concentration. These data suggest that CAPs inhalation is associated with subtle alterations in pulmonary and systemic cell profiles, and specific components of CAPs may be responsible for these biologic responses.
使用哈佛环境颗粒物浓缩器(HAPC)对犬类暴露于浓缩环境颗粒物(CAPs)后的肺部炎症和血液学反应进行了研究。对于肺部炎症研究,将正常犬成对暴露于CAPs或过滤空气中(配对研究),连续3天,每天暴露6小时。对于血液学研究,犬连续3天每天暴露6小时,其中一只接受CAPs暴露,另一只同时暴露于过滤空气中;暴露交叉在下周进行(交叉研究)。CAPs暴露样本的物理化学特征包括颗粒物质量、粒径分布和成分测量。当比较所有CAPs暴露和所有假暴露时,未发现生物学反应的统计学差异。然而,CAPs暴露时生物学反应的变异性要高得多。随后的探索性图形分析和混合线性回归分析表明CAPs成分与生物学反应之间存在关联。应用因子分析对配对和交叉实验的成分数据进行分析,以确定CAPs样本中始终相互关联的元素。在配对实验中,识别出四个因子;在交叉研究中,共观察到六个因子。将支气管肺泡灌洗(BAL)和血液学数据与因子得分进行回归分析。BAL中性粒细胞百分比增加、外周血白细胞(WBC)总数增加、循环中性粒细胞增加和循环淋巴细胞增加与铝/硅因子增加有关。循环中性粒细胞增加和BAL巨噬细胞增加与钒/镍因子有关。仅使用CAPs暴露第三天的成分数据时,BAL中性粒细胞增加与溴/铅因子有关。红细胞计数和血红蛋白水平的显著降低与硫因子相关。BAL或血液学参数与CAPs总质量浓度增加无关。这些数据表明,吸入CAPs与肺部和全身细胞谱的细微改变有关,CAPs的特定成分可能是这些生物学反应的原因。