Gingerich W J, Eisengart S
Mandel School of Applied Social Sciences, Case Western Reserve University, 10900 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44106-7164, USA.
Fam Process. 2000 Winter;39(4):477-98. doi: 10.1111/j.1545-5300.2000.39408.x.
Solution-focused brief therapy (SFBT) is a new and increasingly used therapeutic approach that focuses on helping clients construct solutions rather than solve problems. The approach evolved in a clinical context amid many anecdotal reports of success from both therapists and clients, but it has not been subjected to controlled empirical testing until very recently. In this article we critically review all of the controlled outcome studies of SFBT to date (N = 15) to assess the extent to which SFBT has received empirical support. Five studies were well-controlled and all showed positive outcomes--four found SFBT to be better than no treatment or standard institutional services, and one found SFBT to be comparable to a known intervention: Interpersonal Psychotherapy for Depression (IPT). Findings from the remaining 10 studies, which we consider moderately or poorly controlled, were consistent with a hypothesis of SFBT effectiveness. We conclude that the 15 studies provide preliminary support for the efficacy of SFBT but do not permit a definitive conclusion. Our critique highlights areas where methodology in future studies can be strengthened to provide more conclusive evidence of SFBT efficacy.
聚焦解决短期治疗(SFBT)是一种新兴且使用日益广泛的治疗方法,它侧重于帮助来访者构建解决方案而非解决问题。这种方法是在临床环境中发展起来的,有许多治疗师和来访者成功的轶事报道,但直到最近才进行了对照实证测试。在本文中,我们批判性地回顾了迄今为止所有关于SFBT的对照结果研究(N = 15),以评估SFBT获得实证支持的程度。五项研究控制良好,均显示出积极的结果——四项研究发现SFBT比无治疗或标准机构服务更好,一项研究发现SFBT与一种已知干预措施相当:抑郁症人际心理治疗(IPT)。其余10项研究我们认为控制程度中等或较差,其结果与SFBT有效性的假设一致。我们得出结论,这15项研究为SFBT的疗效提供了初步支持,但无法得出明确结论。我们的批评突出了未来研究中可以加强方法学的领域,以提供关于SFBT疗效更确凿的证据。