Hjalmarson A, Fagerberg B
Institute of Heart and Lung Diseases, Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Göteborg, Sweden.
Basic Res Cardiol. 2000;95 Suppl 1:I98-103. doi: 10.1007/s003950070017.
This survival study was designed to address whether beta-1-blockade utilizing metoprolol CR/XL (controlled release/extended release) once daily added to standard therapy reduces mortality and morbidity in patients with decreased ejection fraction and symptoms of heart failure. Enrolled in a double-blind randomized study were 3991 patients with chronic heart failure in NYHA functional class II-IV and ejection fraction < or = 0.40 stabilized on optimal standard therapy. Randomization was preceded by a 2-week single blind placebo run-in period. The study medication was uptitrated during 8 weeks starting with 12.5 mg (NYHA functional class III-IV) or 25 mg once daily (NYHA functional class II). The target dose was 200 mg once daily. The primary endpoints were all-cause mortality and combined all-cause mortality and hospitalization (time to first event) and other objectives were cause-specific data on hospitalization, NYHA functional class and quality of life. Mean follow-up time was 1 year. All-cause mortality was reduced in the metoprolol CR/XL group compared with the placebo group, 145 versus 217 deaths, 7.2% per patient year of follow-up versus 11.0% with a relative risk of 0.66 (95% CI 0.53-0.81, nominal p = 0.00009, p adjusted for interim analysis = 0.0062). This effect was consistent across all predefined subgroups. Sudden deaths were fewer in the metoprolol group (79 versus 132 deaths), RR 0.59 (p = 0.0002). Also deaths from worsening heart failure were fewer in the metoprolol group (30 versus 58 deaths), RR 0.51 (p = 0.0023). The combined endpoint total mortality or all-cause hospitalizations was also reduced by metoprolol (641 versus 767 events), RR 0.81 (p = 0.00012). Total mortality or hospitalizations due to worsening heart failure was also reduced (311 versus 439 events), RR 0.69 (p < 0.00001). The number of hospitalizations due to worsening heart failure (317 versus 451, p < 0.00001) and days in hospital due to worsening heart failure (3401 versus 5303 days, p < 0.00001) were also reduced by metoprolol. There was also an improvement in NYHA functional class, assessed by the physicians as well as the McMaster Overall Treatment Evaluation questionnaire (OTE), assessed by the patients (p = 0.028 and p = 0.089, respectively). Permanent early discontinuation was 13.9% in the metoprolol group and 15.3% in the placebo group (RR = 0.90). In conclusion, in patients with symptomatic heart failure metoprolol CR/XL once daily improved survival by 34%, sudden death by 41%, and deaths from worsening of heart failure by 49%. In addition to improvement of survival there was also a reduced need of hospitalizations for worsening heart failure and an improved NYHA functional class and of quality of life assessed in a substudy. Metoprolol was well tolerated with no difference in early discontinuation rate from placebo treatment.
这项生存研究旨在探讨,对于射血分数降低且有心力衰竭症状的患者,在标准治疗基础上加用每日一次的美托洛尔控释/缓释片(CR/XL)进行β-1受体阻滞,是否能降低死亡率和发病率。3991例纽约心脏协会(NYHA)心功能II-IV级、射血分数≤0.40且已在最佳标准治疗下病情稳定的慢性心力衰竭患者,被纳入一项双盲随机研究。随机分组前有一个为期2周的单盲安慰剂导入期。研究药物在8周内逐渐滴定剂量,NYHA心功能III-IV级患者起始剂量为12.5mg,NYHA心功能II级患者起始剂量为25mg,均为每日一次。目标剂量为每日200mg。主要终点为全因死亡率以及全因死亡率与住院率合并(首次事件发生时间),其他目标为住院的病因特异性数据、NYHA心功能分级及生活质量。平均随访时间为1年。与安慰剂组相比,美托洛尔CR/XL组全因死亡率降低,分别为145例死亡和217例死亡,随访期间每年每位患者的死亡率为7.2%,而安慰剂组为11.0%,相对风险为0.66(95%置信区间0.53 - 0.81,名义p = 0.00009,经中期分析调整后的p = 0.0062)。这种效果在所有预先定义的亚组中均一致。美托洛尔组猝死病例较少(79例死亡对132例死亡),RR为0.59(p = 0.0002)。美托洛尔组因心力衰竭恶化导致的死亡也较少(30例死亡对58例死亡),RR为0.51(p = 0.0023)。美托洛尔还降低了全因死亡率或住院率这一合并终点(641例事件对767例事件),RR为0.81(p = 0.00012)。因心力衰竭恶化导致的全因死亡率或住院率也降低了(311例事件对439例事件),RR为0.69(p < 0.00001)。美托洛尔还减少了因心力衰竭恶化导致的住院次数(317次对451次,p < 0.00001)以及因心力衰竭恶化导致的住院天数(3401天对5303天,p < 0.00001)。NYHA心功能分级也有改善,医生评估以及患者通过麦克马斯特总体治疗评估问卷(OTE)评估的结果(分别为p = 0.028和p = 0.089)。美托洛尔组永久提前停药率为13.9%,安慰剂组为15.3%(RR = 0.90)。总之,对于有症状的心力衰竭患者,每日一次的美托洛尔CR/XL使生存率提高了34%,猝死率降低了41%,因心力衰竭恶化导致的死亡率降低了49%。除了提高生存率外,因心力衰竭恶化导致的住院需求也减少了,NYHA心功能分级得到改善,且在一项子研究中评估的生活质量也有所提高。美托洛尔耐受性良好,与安慰剂治疗的提前停药率无差异。