Kanemoto K, Tsuji T, Kawasaki J
Kansai Regional Epilepsy Center, Utano National Hospital, Kyoto, Japan.
Epilepsia. 2001 Jan;42(1):98-103. doi: 10.1046/j.1528-1157.2001.09000.x.
We sought to examine interictal psychoses based on the international epilepsy classification and DSM IV criteria, with special attention paid to epilepsy types as well as to subcategories of psychoses. One hundred thirty-two outpatients were studied, each with definite evidence of both epilepsy and interictal psychosis clearly demarcated from postictal psychosis. We compared them with 2,773 other epilepsy outpatients as a control. Risk factors for psychosis were examined within the temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) group and the more extended group of symptomatic localization-related epilepsy. Further, nuclear schizophrenia and other nonschizophrenic psychotic disorders were compared. We confirmed a close correlation between TLE and interictal psychoses. Within the TLE group, only early epilepsy onset and a history of prolonged febrile convulsions were revealed to be significantly associated with interictal psychosis. Within the symptomatic localization-related epilepsy group, such parameters as complex partial seizures, autonomic aura, and temporal EEG foci were closely associated with psychoses. There was also a significant difference between groups as to ictal fear and secondary generalization. Whereas patients with early psychosis onset and a low intelligence quotient were overrepresented in the nuclear schizophrenia group, drug-induced psychosis and alternative psychosis were underrepresented. TLE proved to be preferentially associated with interictal psychoses. Within the TLE group, medial TLE in particular was found to be more closely associated with psychosis. Our data support the original postulation of Landolt, stating that alternative or drug-induced psychoses constitute a definite subgroup of interictal psychoses, which are different from chronic epileptic psychoses that simulate schizophrenia.
我们试图根据国际癫痫分类和《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版标准来研究发作间期精神病,特别关注癫痫类型以及精神病的子类别。对132名门诊患者进行了研究,每位患者都有明确的癫痫证据且发作间期精神病与发作后精神病有明显区分。我们将他们与2773名其他癫痫门诊患者作为对照进行比较。在颞叶癫痫(TLE)组和症状性定位相关癫痫的更广泛组中检查了精神病的危险因素。此外,对核型精神分裂症和其他非精神分裂症性精神障碍进行了比较。我们证实了TLE与发作间期精神病之间存在密切相关性。在TLE组中,仅发现癫痫早发和长期热性惊厥史与发作间期精神病显著相关。在症状性定位相关癫痫组中,复杂部分性发作、自主神经先兆和颞叶脑电图病灶等参数与精神病密切相关。在发作期恐惧和继发性泛化方面,两组之间也存在显著差异。核型精神分裂症组中精神病早发和智商低的患者比例过高,而药物性精神病和交替性精神病的比例过低。事实证明,TLE与发作间期精神病优先相关。在TLE组中,特别是内侧TLE被发现与精神病关系更密切。我们的数据支持Landolt最初的假设,即交替性或药物性精神病构成发作间期精神病的一个明确亚组,它们不同于模拟精神分裂症的慢性癫痫性精神病。