Spencer A J
Dental School, University of Adelaide.
Aust Dent J. 2000 Dec;45(4):224-34. doi: 10.1111/j.1834-7819.2000.tb00256.x.
Mercury in dentistry has re-emerged as a contentious issue in public health, predominantly because so many people are inadvertently exposed to mercury in order to obtain the benefits of dental amalgam fillings, and the risks remain difficult to interpret. This commentary aims to examine the issues involved in public policy assessment of the continued use of dental amalgam in dentistry. More than 30 per cent of Australian adults are concerned about mercury from dental amalgam fillings but only a small percentage report having their amalgam fillings removed. The placement of dental fillings nearly halved between 1983 and 1997, but many millions of dental amalgam fillings exist in the Australian community. These fillings release mercury (mercury vapour or inorganic ions) at a low level (about 2-5 micrograms/day in an adult). Evidence on the health effect of dental amalgams comes from studies of the association between their presence and signs or symptoms of adverse effects or health changes after removal of dental amalgam fillings. More formal risk assessment studies focus on occupational exposure to mercury and health effects. Numerous methodological issues make their interpretation difficult but new research will continue to challenge policymakers. Policy will also reflect prudent and cautious approaches, encouraging minimization of exposure to mercury in potentially more sensitive population groups. Wider environmental concerns and decreasing tolerance of exposure to other mercury compounds (for example, methylmercury in seafoods) will ensure the use of mercury in dentistry remains an issue, necessitating dentists keep their patients informed of health risks and respect their choices.
牙科用汞再度成为公共卫生领域一个有争议的问题,主要是因为很多人为了获得汞合金补牙的益处而在不经意间接触到汞,而且相关风险仍难以解读。本评论旨在探讨牙科持续使用汞合金在公共政策评估中所涉及的问题。超过30%的澳大利亚成年人担心汞合金补牙中的汞,但只有一小部分人报告去除了汞合金补牙材料。1983年至1997年间,补牙的比例几乎减半,但澳大利亚社区仍有数以百万计的汞合金补牙材料。这些补牙材料会以低水平(成年人约为每天2 - 5微克)释放汞(汞蒸气或无机离子)。关于汞合金补牙对健康影响的证据来自对其存在与去除汞合金补牙材料后不良反应或健康变化的体征或症状之间关联的研究。更正式的风险评估研究聚焦于职业性汞暴露及其对健康的影响。众多方法学问题使其难以解读,但新的研究将继续给政策制定者带来挑战。政策也将反映出谨慎的做法,鼓励在可能更敏感的人群中尽量减少汞暴露。更广泛的环境问题以及对接触其他汞化合物(如海鲜中的甲基汞)的容忍度降低,将确保牙科用汞仍是一个问题,这就要求牙医让患者了解健康风险并尊重他们的选择。