Frappell P B, Hinds D S, Boggs D F
Department of Zoology, La Trobe University, Melbourne, Victoria 3083, Australia.
Physiol Biochem Zool. 2001 Jan-Feb;74(1):75-89. doi: 10.1086/319300.
Allometric equations can be useful in comparative physiology in a number of ways, not the least of which include assessing whether a particular species deviates from the norm for its size and phylogenetic group with respect to some specific physiological process or determining how differences in design among groups may be reflected in differences in function. The allometric equations for respiratory variables in birds were developed 30 yr ago by Lasiewski and Calder and presented as "preliminary" because they were based on a small number of species. With the expanded data base now available to reconstruct these allometries and the call for taking account of the nonindependence of species in this process through a phylogenetically independent contrasts (PIC) approach, we have developed new allometric equations for respiratory variables in birds using both the traditional and PIC approaches. On the whole, the new equations agree with the old ones with only minor changes in the coefficients, and the primary difference between the traditional and PIC approaches is in the broader confidence intervals given by the latter. We confirm the lower VE/VO2 ratio for birds compared to mammals and observe a common scaling of inspiratory flow and oxygen consumption for birds as has been reported for mammals. Use of allometrics and comparisons among avian groups are also discussed.
异速生长方程在比较生理学中有多种用途,其中至少包括评估某一特定物种在某些特定生理过程方面是否偏离其体型和系统发育群体的正常水平,或者确定群体间设计上的差异如何反映在功能差异上。鸟类呼吸变量的异速生长方程是30年前由拉西耶夫斯基和考尔德提出的,当时被称为“初步的”,因为它们是基于少数物种得出的。鉴于现在有了更广泛的数据库来重建这些异速生长关系,并且有人呼吁在这个过程中通过系统发育独立对比(PIC)方法考虑物种的非独立性,我们使用传统方法和PIC方法为鸟类的呼吸变量开发了新的异速生长方程。总体而言,新方程与旧方程基本一致,只是系数有微小变化,传统方法和PIC方法的主要区别在于后者给出的置信区间更宽。我们证实了鸟类与哺乳动物相比具有更低的VE/VO2比值,并观察到鸟类吸气流量和耗氧量的常见缩放关系,这与哺乳动物的情况类似。本文还讨论了异速生长法的应用以及鸟类群体之间的比较。