Mechem C C, Barger J, Shofer F S, Dickinson E T
Department of Emergency Medicine, Hospital of the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104-4283, USA.
Acad Emerg Med. 2001 Mar;8(3):231-6. doi: 10.1111/j.1553-2712.2001.tb01298.x.
To determine the short-term outcome of patients with a known seizure disorder who have a seizure, are evaluated by out-of-hospital care providers, and refuse transport.
This was a prospective study conducted over a 15-month period. Philadelphia Fire Department paramedics contacted a medical command physician whenever they encountered a patient with a known seizure disorder who had had another seizure and was refusing transport. After confirming that the patient had the mental capacity to refuse care and understood the associated risks, the physician recorded the patient's name, address, and telephone number. Beginning three days later, a registered nurse attempted to reach the patient by telephone and administer a brief questionnaire about his or her medical outcome. Patients not reached by telephone were sent a certified letter. The names of patients lost to follow-up were compared with medical examiner records to confirm that they had not died during the follow-up period.
Of 63 patients enrolled in the study, 52 (82.5%) were reached in follow-up. Of these, three (5.8%) had another seizure within 72 hours and recontacted 911. One of these patients (1.9%) was hospitalized. Twenty (38.5%) patients contacted their primary care physicians. There were no deaths, including patients lost to follow-up.
Most patients (94.2%) who were evaluated by out-of-hospital care providers for a seizure and refused transport had no further seizure activity in the subsequent 72 hours. However, because there is a risk of recurrence, out-of-hospital care providers and medical command physicians should ensure that patients understand the risks of refusal.
确定已知患有癫痫疾病的患者发生癫痫发作后,由院外急救人员进行评估且拒绝转运的短期结局。
这是一项为期15个月的前瞻性研究。费城消防部门的护理人员在遇到已知患有癫痫疾病且再次发作并拒绝转运的患者时,会联系医疗指挥医师。在确认患者有拒绝治疗的精神能力且理解相关风险后,医师记录患者的姓名、地址和电话号码。从三天后开始,一名注册护士试图通过电话联系患者,并就其医疗结局进行简短问卷调查。未通过电话联系到的患者会收到一封挂号信。将失访患者的姓名与法医记录进行比较,以确认他们在随访期间未死亡。
在纳入研究的63例患者中,52例(82.5%)在随访中被联系到。其中,3例(5.8%)在72小时内再次发作并再次拨打911。这些患者中有1例(1.9%)住院治疗。20例(38.5%)患者联系了他们的初级保健医生。包括失访患者在内,无死亡病例。
大多数接受院外急救人员评估癫痫发作并拒绝转运的患者(94.2%)在随后72小时内没有进一步的癫痫发作活动。然而,由于存在复发风险,院外急救人员和医疗指挥医师应确保患者了解拒绝治疗的风险。