Copp A J, Greene N D
Neural Development Unit, Institute of Child Health, University College, London, 30 Guilford Street, London WC1N 1EH.
Indian J Pediatr. 2000 Dec;67(12):915-21. doi: 10.1007/BF02723958.
Folic acid has been demonstrated in clinical trials to reduce significantly the recurrence (and probably occurrence) of neural tube defects (NTD). In the U.K., there has been no decline in prevalence of NTD since the publication of the findings with folic acid. This article examines a series of questions relating to the action of folic acid, with emphasis on the use of mouse models as a source of experimental information which cannot easily be obtained by direct study of humans. Several mouse genetic NTD models exhibit sensitivity to prevention by folic acid, whereas other mice which develop morphologically similar NTD are resistant. Folic acid normalises neurulation in the sensitive mouse strains, providing evidence for a direct effect on the developing embryo, not on the pregnant female: Mouse studies do not support the proposed action of folic acid in encouraging the in utero demise of affected fetuses (i.e. terathanasia). Polymorphic variants of several folate-related enzymes have been shown to influence risk of NTD in humans and an inherited abnormality of folate metabolism has been demonstrated in one mouse NTD model. However, the biochemical basis of the action of folic acid in preventing NTD remains to be determined in detail. NTD in one folate-resistant mouse strain can be prevented by myo-inositol, both in utero and in vitro, raising the possibility of a therapeutic role also in humans. Gene-gene interactions seem likely to underlie the majority of NTD, suggesting that poly-therapy involving folic acid and other agents, such as myo-inositol, may prove more effective in preventing NTD than folic acid treatment alone.
临床试验已证明,叶酸能显著降低神经管缺陷(NTD)的复发率(可能还有发病率)。在英国,自叶酸研究结果公布以来,NTD的患病率并未下降。本文探讨了一系列与叶酸作用相关的问题,重点是使用小鼠模型作为实验信息来源,而这些信息难以通过直接研究人类轻易获得。几种小鼠遗传性NTD模型对叶酸预防表现出敏感性,而其他出现形态学上类似NTD的小鼠则具有抗性。叶酸使敏感小鼠品系的神经胚形成正常化,这为其对发育中的胚胎而非怀孕母鼠有直接作用提供了证据:小鼠研究不支持叶酸促使子宫内受影响胎儿死亡(即致畸性安乐死)的假设作用。已表明几种叶酸相关酶的多态性变体影响人类患NTD的风险,并且在一种小鼠NTD模型中已证明存在叶酸代谢的遗传异常。然而,叶酸预防NTD作用的生化基础仍有待详细确定。一种叶酸抗性小鼠品系的NTD在子宫内和体外均可通过肌醇预防,这增加了肌醇在人类中也具有治疗作用的可能性。基因-基因相互作用似乎可能是大多数NTD的基础,这表明涉及叶酸和其他药物(如肌醇)的联合治疗可能比单独使用叶酸治疗在预防NTD方面更有效。