Borton D C, Walker K, Pirpiris M, Nattrass G R, Graham H K
Orthopaedic Department, Murdoch Children's Research Institute, Royal Children's Hospital, Melbourne, Australia.
J Bone Joint Surg Br. 2001 Apr;83(3):364-70. doi: 10.1302/0301-620x.83b3.10827.
We assessed the medium-term outcome of three methods of isolated calf lengthening in cerebral palsy by clinical examination, observational gait analysis and, where appropriate, instrumented gait analysis. The procedures used were percutaneous lengthening of tendo Achillis, open Z-lengthening of tendo Achillis and lengthening of the gastrosoleus aponeurosis (Baker's procedure). We reviewed 195 procedures in 134 children; 45 had hemiplegia, 65 diplegia and 24 quadriplegia. We established the incidence of calcaneus and recurrent equinus and identified 'at-risk' groups for each. At follow-up, 42% had satisfactory calf length, 22% had recurrent equinus and 36% calcaneus. The incidence of calcaneus in girls at follow-up was significantly higher (p = 0.002) while boys had an increased rate of recurrent equinus (p = 0.012). Children with diplegia who had surgery when aged eight years or younger had a 44% risk of calcaneus, while those over eight years had a 19% risk (p = 0.046). Percutaneous lengthening of tendo Achillis in diplegia was the least predictable, only 38% having a satisfactory outcome compared with 50% in the other procedures. The incidence of recurrent equinus in hemiplegic patients was 38%. Only 4% developed calcaneus. The type of surgery did not influence the outcome in patients with hemiplegia or quadriplegia. Severity of involvement, female gender, age at operation of less than eight years and percutaneous lengthening of tendo Achillis were 'risk factors' for calcaneus. Hemiplegia, male gender, and an aponeurosis muscle lengthening increased the risk of recurrent equinus.
我们通过临床检查、观察性步态分析以及在适当情况下进行仪器化步态分析,评估了三种孤立性小腿延长方法用于治疗脑瘫的中期效果。所采用的手术方法为经皮跟腱延长术、开放性跟腱Z形延长术以及腓肠肌筋膜延长术(贝克手术)。我们回顾了134名儿童的195例手术;其中45例为偏瘫,65例为双瘫,24例为四肢瘫。我们确定了跟骨畸形和复发性马蹄足的发生率,并为每种情况确定了“高危”群体。随访时,42%的患者小腿长度令人满意,22%有复发性马蹄足,36%有跟骨畸形。随访时女孩跟骨畸形的发生率显著更高(p = 0.002),而男孩复发性马蹄足的发生率更高(p = 0.012)。8岁及以下接受手术的双瘫儿童发生跟骨畸形的风险为44%,而8岁以上儿童的风险为19%(p = 0.046)。双瘫患者经皮跟腱延长术的效果最不可预测,只有38%的患者效果令人满意,而其他手术方法为50%。偏瘫患者复发性马蹄足的发生率为38%。只有4%发生跟骨畸形。手术类型对偏瘫或四肢瘫患者的效果没有影响。受累严重程度、女性性别、手术年龄小于8岁以及经皮跟腱延长术是跟骨畸形的“危险因素”。偏瘫、男性性别以及筋膜肌肉延长术增加了复发性马蹄足的风险。