Demissie S, Green R C, Mucci L, Tziavas S, Martelli K, Bang K, Coons L, Bourque S, Buchillon D, Johnson K, Smith T, Sharrow N, Lautenschlager N, Friedland R, Cupples L A, Farrer L A
Data Coordinating Center, Boston University Schools of Medicine and Public Health, Boston, Mass., USA.
Neuroepidemiology. 2001 May;20(2):105-11. doi: 10.1159/000054768.
The study evaluated the reliability of data obtained from proxy informants. The index subjects in this study were 81 nondemented participants in the Multi-Institutional Research in Alzheimer Genetic Epidemiology (MIRAGE) study. These index subjects and 159 proxy informants, identified by the index subjects, participated in the study. The kappa statistic with multiple raters per subject (for dichotomous variables) and the intraclass correlation coefficient (for continuous variables) were used to measure reliability. Among proxy respondents who provided answers, there was excellent agreement between proxy responses and the responses of the index subjects (0.7 < or = kappa < or =0.9), with the exception of questions about head injury (kappa = 0.4). A large proportion (>90%) of the proxy informants in this study were able to provide information on most items. Higher nonresponse rates (as high as 30%) were observed for medication history and women's health questions. This study supports the reliability of proxy responses for most categories of questions that are elicited in typical epidemiological studies, including the MIRAGE study.
该研究评估了从代理 informant 处获得的数据的可靠性。本研究中的指标对象是阿尔茨海默病遗传流行病学多机构研究(MIRAGE 研究)中的 81 名无痴呆参与者。这些指标对象以及由指标对象确定的 159 名代理 informant 参与了研究。使用针对每个受试者有多个评分者的卡方统计量(用于二分变量)和组内相关系数(用于连续变量)来衡量可靠性。在提供答案的代理受访者中,除了关于头部受伤的问题(卡方 = 0.4)外,代理回答与指标对象的回答之间存在极好的一致性(0.7≤卡方≤0.9)。本研究中很大一部分(>90%)的代理 informant 能够提供大多数项目的信息。在用药史和女性健康问题方面观察到较高的无回答率(高达 30%)。本研究支持在典型的流行病学研究(包括 MIRAGE 研究)中引出的大多数问题类别的代理回答的可靠性。