Ishihara J, Sobue T, Yamamoto S, Sasaki S, Akabane M, Tsugane S
National Cancer Center Research Institute, Tokyo and Kashiwa, Japan.
Eur J Clin Nutr. 2001 May;55(5):360-5. doi: 10.1038/sj.ejcn.1601164.
To evaluate reproducibility and validity of a self-administered food frequency questionnaire (FFQ) to determine the dietary supplement use.
Questionnaire data were compared with dietary records (DR) in four 7 day periods for validity. FFQ1 and FFQ2 administered at an interval of approximately one year were compared for reproducibility.
A total of 361 samples were selected for a validation study of a questionnaire from the subgroup of the Japan Public Health Center-based prospective Study on cancer and cardiovascular disease (JPHC Study) cohort II. Categories of dietary supplements in the FFQ were 'multivitamins', 'beta-carotene', 'vitamin C', 'vitamin E', and 'other supplements'. For each category, inquiries were made as to the brand name, frequency and duration of use. A dietary supplement user was defined as a subject who used a dietary supplement one or more times a week for a year or longer.
Prevalence of overall supplement use was 10.9%. Percentage agreement between FFQ1 and FFQ2 was 91.7%. Sensitivity and specificity of supplement use by FFQ were 80.6% and 89.2%, respectively. Sensitivity was high for 'vitamin C'. When the self-reported categories were corrected, sensitivity for 'multivitamins' and 'vitamin E' improved.
The FFQ on dietary supplements used for the JPHC 5 y follow-up survey was valid to determine overall use and well-defined dietary supplement use such as vitamin C. Categories must be corrected when determining multivitamin and 'vitamin E'.
评估一份用于确定膳食补充剂使用情况的自填式食物频率问卷(FFQ)的可重复性和有效性。
将问卷数据与四个为期7天的饮食记录(DR)进行比较以评估有效性。比较间隔约一年发放的FFQ1和FFQ2以评估可重复性。
从日本公共卫生中心前瞻性癌症与心血管疾病研究(JPHC研究)队列II的亚组中选取361个样本进行问卷的验证研究。FFQ中的膳食补充剂类别为“多种维生素”、“β-胡萝卜素”、“维生素C”、“维生素E”和“其他补充剂”。针对每个类别,询问品牌名称、使用频率和持续时间。膳食补充剂使用者定义为每周使用膳食补充剂一次或多次且持续一年或更长时间的受试者。
总体补充剂使用率为10.9%。FFQ1和FFQ2之间的百分比一致性为91.7%。FFQ对补充剂使用的敏感性和特异性分别为80.6%和89.2%。“维生素C”的敏感性较高。当对自我报告的类别进行校正后,“多种维生素”和“维生素E”的敏感性有所提高。
用于JPHC 5年随访调查的膳食补充剂FFQ对于确定总体使用情况以及明确界定的膳食补充剂使用情况(如维生素C)是有效的。在确定多种维生素和“维生素E”时,类别必须进行校正。