Shimon I, Cohen Z R, Ram Z, Hadani M
Institute of Endocrinology, Chaim Sheba Medical Center, Tel-Hashomer, Israel.
Neurosurgery. 2001 Jun;48(6):1239-43; discussion 1244-5. doi: 10.1097/00006123-200106000-00008.
Transsphenoidal surgery is the preferred treatment modality for growth hormone (GH)-secreting pituitary adenomas. In many series, the reported postoperative remission is based mainly on achievement of GH levels less than 2 ng/ml. Strict criteria for insulin-like growth factor I normalization and even lower GH levels (<1 ng/ml) are now suggested to define cure of acromegaly, but the evidence does not yet support such low GH levels in epidemiological follow-up. We analyzed our postoperative results in a large cohort of patients with acromegaly.
Ninety-eight patients harboring GH-secreting adenomas (46 microadenomas and 52 macroadenomas) underwent transsphenoidal surgery between 1990 and 1999. Ninety-one patients were operated for the first time, and 12 patients underwent reoperations because of previous surgical failure (7 had undergone surgery elsewhere previously). Biochemical remission was defined as a repeated fasting or glucose-suppressed GH level of 2 ng/ml or less, and a normal insulin-like growth factor I level.
Remission was achieved in 74% of all patients after one operation, including 84% of patients with microadenomas and 64% of patients with macroadenomas. Seventy-three percent of patients with macroadenomas 11 to 20 mm in size achieved remission, as compared with a 20% remission rate for patients with adenomas larger than 20 mm. Patients with preoperative random GH levels lower than 50 ng/ml had a better outcome (85% remission), whereas GH greater than 50 ng/ml was associated with remission in 30% of the patients. Only one of the patients (8%) with postoperative active disease who underwent a second operation achieved remission. Recurrence was rare (one patient), and all failed surgical attempts could be detected during the immediate postoperative evaluation.
On the basis of strict postoperative GH and insulin-like growth factor I criteria to define remission, our series demonstrates the efficacy of transsphenoidal surgery for acromegalic patients with microadenomas and noninvasive macroadenomas. However, patients with large adenomas (>20 mm) and preoperative GH greater than 50 ng/ml have a poor prognosis and require adjunctive medical or radiation therapy to control GH hypersecretion.
经蝶窦手术是生长激素(GH)分泌型垂体腺瘤的首选治疗方式。在许多研究系列中,报告的术后缓解主要基于GH水平低于2 ng/ml。现在建议采用严格的胰岛素样生长因子I正常化标准以及更低的GH水平(<1 ng/ml)来定义肢端肥大症的治愈,但在流行病学随访中,尚无证据支持如此低的GH水平。我们分析了一大群肢端肥大症患者的术后结果。
1990年至1999年间,98例患有GH分泌性腺瘤的患者(46例微腺瘤和52例大腺瘤)接受了经蝶窦手术。91例患者首次接受手术,12例患者因先前手术失败而接受再次手术(7例患者此前在其他地方接受过手术)。生化缓解定义为重复空腹或葡萄糖抑制后GH水平为2 ng/ml或更低,且胰岛素样生长因子I水平正常。
所有患者中,一次手术后74%实现缓解,其中微腺瘤患者缓解率为84%,大腺瘤患者为64%。大小为11至20 mm的大腺瘤患者中,73%实现缓解,而腺瘤大于20 mm的患者缓解率为20%。术前随机GH水平低于50 ng/ml的患者预后较好(缓解率85%),而GH大于50 ng/ml的患者缓解率为30%。接受二次手术的术后仍有活动性疾病的患者中,只有1例(8%)实现缓解。复发罕见(1例患者),所有手术失败情况在术后即刻评估中均可检测到。
基于严格的术后GH和胰岛素样生长因子I标准来定义缓解,我们的研究系列证明了经蝶窦手术对微腺瘤和非侵袭性大腺瘤肢端肥大症患者的疗效。然而,大腺瘤(>20 mm)且术前GH大于50 ng/ml的患者预后较差,需要辅助药物或放射治疗以控制GH分泌过多。