Khafif A, Lopez-Garza J R, Medina J E
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, The University of Oklahoma Health Sciences Center, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, USA.
Laryngoscope. 2001 Jun;111(6):1088-90. doi: 10.1097/00005537-200106000-00029.
Dissection of the lower jugular level of lymph nodes (level IV), as part of an elective neck dissection, has been advocated recently for all patients with oral tongue cancer because of the possibility of "skip metastases" to levels III and IV. The current study was undertaken to evaluate the need to perform a dissection of level IV in patients with oral tongue cancer with no clinical evidence of nodal metastases.
Fifty-one patients with T1-3, N0 squamous cell carcinoma of the oral tongue were treated with a partial glossectomy and a selective neck dissection of levels I, II, and III. When enlarged nodes were encountered during surgery in level II or III, the dissection was extended to include the nodes in level IV. Involvement of level IV was determined either by the presence of carcinoma on pathological examination or by the development of recurrence in the untreated level IV during a follow-up period of at least 2 years.
Level IV was resected as part of the specimen in 17 of the 51 patients and metastatic tumor was found in this level in only one patient. At an average follow-up of 4.1 years, only one patient recurred at level IV, which had been addressed at the initial neck dissection. Consequently, the rate of metastases to undissected level IV was 2%.
Metastases to level IV lymph nodes is rare in patients with T1-T3, N0 oral tongue cancer. Dissection of these nodes only when there is intraoperative suspicion of metastases in levels II or III does not increase the risk or recurrence of tumor in the neck.
由于存在向Ⅲ区和Ⅳ区“跳跃性转移”的可能性,近期有人主张,对于所有口腔舌癌患者,作为择期颈部清扫术的一部分,均应对颈下组淋巴结(Ⅳ区)进行清扫。本研究旨在评估对于无临床淋巴结转移证据的口腔舌癌患者,是否有必要清扫Ⅳ区淋巴结。
51例T1-3、N0期口腔舌鳞状细胞癌患者接受了部分舌切除术及Ⅰ、Ⅱ、Ⅲ区选择性颈部清扫术。术中若在Ⅱ区或Ⅲ区发现肿大淋巴结,则扩大清扫范围,包括Ⅳ区淋巴结。通过病理检查发现癌组织或在至少2年的随访期内未处理的Ⅳ区出现复发,来确定Ⅳ区是否受累。
51例患者中有17例将Ⅳ区作为标本的一部分予以切除,仅1例在该区发现转移瘤。平均随访4.1年,仅1例患者在Ⅳ区复发,而该区在初次颈部清扫时已作处理。因此,未清扫的Ⅳ区发生转移的比例为2%。
T1-T3、N0期口腔舌癌患者发生Ⅳ区淋巴结转移的情况罕见。仅在术中怀疑Ⅱ区或Ⅲ区有转移时才清扫这些淋巴结,不会增加颈部肿瘤的风险或复发率。