Messer H H
Restorative Dentistry, School of Dental Science, University of Melbourne, 711 Elizabeth Street, Melbourne, Victoria, 3000.
Aust Endod J. 1999 Dec;25(3):124-32. doi: 10.1111/j.1747-4477.1999.tb00119.x.
Clinical judgement in endodontics consists of much more than diagnosis and treatment planning for the affected tooth. The issues involved in clinical judgement and decision making can be summarised by three questions: 1. Is endodontic treatment appropriate for the patient? Endodontic treatment should be undertaken only as part of an agreed, comprehensive treatment plan that takes into account patient concerns as well as objective clinical findings. 2. How difficult is the endodontic treatment? The difficulty of the case should be balanced with the skill and experience of the dentist, in deciding whether to manage the case in general practice or to refer the patient to an endodontist. The use of a standard form for assessing the difficulty of each endodontic case will aid in consistent, systematic assessment of patients. An example of such a form is provided. 3. What is the prognosis for the tooth? The outcome of endodontic treatment depends not only on the endodontic treatment but on other factors such as restorability and periodontal status. The prognosis will be compromised by procedural problems and by restorative and periodontal factors. In all but routine cases, the steps involved in decision making may be more complex and less easily resolved than the practical clinical aspects of endodontic therapy.
牙髓病学中的临床判断所包含的内容远不止对患牙的诊断和治疗计划。临床判断和决策中涉及的问题可以用三个问题来概括:1. 牙髓治疗对患者是否合适?牙髓治疗应仅作为商定的综合治疗计划的一部分进行,该计划要考虑患者的关切以及客观的临床检查结果。2. 牙髓治疗的难度如何?在决定是在普通诊所处理该病例还是将患者转诊给牙髓病专科医生时,应将病例的难度与牙医的技能和经验相权衡。使用标准表格评估每个牙髓病例的难度将有助于对患者进行一致、系统的评估。文中提供了这样一个表格的示例。3. 患牙的预后如何?牙髓治疗的结果不仅取决于牙髓治疗,还取决于其他因素,如可修复性和牙周状况。预后会因治疗过程中的问题以及修复和牙周因素而受到影响。除了常规病例外,决策过程中涉及的步骤可能比牙髓治疗实际的临床方面更为复杂,也更难解决。