Zouari O, Gargouri A, Jenzri M, Hadinane R, Slimane N
Institut d'Orthopédie M.T. Kassab, 2010 La Manouba, Tunis, Tunisie.
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot. 2001 Jun;87(4):361-6.
Knee flexion contracture due to quadriceps paralysis is a major handicap in poliomyelitis patients. The patient has to stabilize the knee with the ipsilateral hand to achieve weight bearing and the deformed knee precludes use of orthopedic devices. Extension can be achieved with supracondylar femoral osteotomy if the knee flexion contracture is less than 30 degrees. We assessed functional and anatomic outcome.
We reviewed the files of 87 patients who had undergone 93 supracondylar femoral osteotomies for knee flexion contracture (6 bilateral cases); mean age was 18 years and mean flexion was 25 degrees. The surgical correction was achieved by diaphyseal metaphyseal impaction with resection of an anterior wedge and preservation of the posterior component of the articulation. If some gluteus maximus activity was retained and the tibiotarsal joint was in a slightly equine position, weight bearing in a stable locked position became an automatic postural event even in case of total paralysis of the quadriceps. Osteotomy was not possible if the contracture flexion was greater than 30 degrees due to excessive tension on the vaculonervous bundles. The procedure was equally impossible in children under 12 years of age due to the risk of recurrence subsequent to migration and callus remodeling with bone growth.
Complete extension of the knee was achieved peroperatively in all cases. The most serious complications were three cases of septic arthritis that led to an irreducible stiff knee. In addition, we had two cases of transient paralysis of the common fibular nerve that recovered spontaneously. Bone fusion was achieved in all cases within 30 days. Recurrent flexion contracture was observed in 5 cases and required a revision using the same procedure in 3 or them. Postoperatively, the amplitude gained in knee extension corresponded to the amplitude lost for flexion. Sixty-three patients were able to walk independently without manual stabilization and a knee extension orthesis could be installed for 19 others. Three patients were still unable to walk despite the correction of the knee flexion contracture due to failure of poorly accepted orthopedic devices.
Several conservative methods (physiotherapy, manipulations, successive corrective casts) and surgical procedures (release of posterior soft tissues, Ilizarov technique) have been proposed for the correction of paralytic knee flexion contracture. Supracondylar femoral osteotomy for extension can be useful after the end of growth if the flexion contracture remains below 30 degrees. The procedure is simple and morbidity is relatively low compared with the regularly successful results. When the flexion contracture exceeds 30 degrees, the supracondylar osteotomy cannot be employed due to the risk of stretching the vasculonervous bundles and due to the instability and disorganization of the lower femur. Progressive correction can be proposed for these patients: regular monitoring of the neurological and vascular situation is required. Functional improvement is considerable after correction of knee flexion contracture. The patients can walk more easily, no longer need to stabilize their knee with their hand, and can benefit from orthopedic devises due to the more favorable biomechanical conditions.
股四头肌麻痹导致的膝关节屈曲挛缩是脊髓灰质炎患者的主要致残因素。患者必须用同侧手稳定膝关节以实现负重,而畸形的膝关节妨碍了矫形器械的使用。如果膝关节屈曲挛缩小于30度,可通过股骨髁上截骨术实现伸直。我们评估了功能和解剖学结果。
我们回顾了87例因膝关节屈曲挛缩接受93次股骨髁上截骨术患者的病历(6例双侧手术);平均年龄18岁,平均屈曲度为25度。手术矫正通过骨干-干骺端嵌插,切除前方楔形骨块并保留关节后方部分来实现。如果保留了部分臀大肌活动且胫距关节处于轻度马蹄足位,即使股四头肌完全麻痹,在稳定锁定位置负重也会自动成为一种姿势性动作。如果挛缩屈曲大于30度,由于血管神经束张力过大则无法进行截骨术。由于12岁以下儿童存在骨迁移和骨痂重塑伴骨骼生长导致复发的风险,该手术对他们同样不可行。
所有病例术中均实现了膝关节完全伸直。最严重的并发症是3例化脓性关节炎,导致膝关节僵硬无法恢复。此外,我们有2例腓总神经短暂麻痹,均自行恢复。所有病例均在30天内实现了骨融合。5例出现复发性屈曲挛缩,其中3例需要采用相同手术进行翻修。术后,膝关节伸直增加的幅度与屈曲减少的幅度相当。63例患者能够独立行走而无需手动稳定膝关节,另外19例可安装膝关节伸直矫形器。3例患者尽管矫正了膝关节屈曲挛缩,但由于矫形器械效果不佳仍无法行走。
已提出多种保守方法(物理治疗、手法操作、连续矫正石膏)和手术方法(后方软组织松解、伊里扎洛夫技术)用于矫正麻痹性膝关节屈曲挛缩。如果屈曲挛缩仍低于30度,股骨髁上截骨术在生长结束后可用于伸直膝关节。该手术操作简单,与通常成功的结果相比,发病率相对较低。当屈曲挛缩超过30度时,由于有拉伸血管神经束的风险以及股骨下段的不稳定和结构紊乱,不能采用髁上截骨术。对于这些患者可采用逐步矫正:需要定期监测神经和血管情况。矫正膝关节屈曲挛缩后功能改善显著。患者行走更轻松,不再需要用手稳定膝关节,并且由于生物力学条件更有利,可受益于矫形器械。