Toledano-Alhadef H, Basel-Vanagaite L, Magal N, Davidov B, Ehrlich S, Drasinover V, Taub E, Halpern G J, Ginott N, Shohat M
Department of Pediatrics, Meir Hospital, Sapir Medical Center, Kfar Saba, Israel.
Am J Hum Genet. 2001 Aug;69(2):351-60. doi: 10.1086/321974. Epub 2001 Jul 6.
Fragile-X syndrome is caused by an unstable CGG trinucleotide repeat in the FMR1 gene at Xq27. Intermediate alleles (51-200 repeats) can undergo expansion to the full mutation on transmission from mother to offspring. To evaluate the effectiveness of a fragile-X carrier-screening program, we tested 14,334 Israeli women of child-bearing age for fragile-X carrier status between 1992 and 2000. These women were either preconceptional or pregnant and had no family history of mental retardation. All those found to be carriers of premutation or full-mutation alleles were offered genetic counseling and also prenatal diagnosis, if applicable. We identified 207 carriers of an allele with >50 repeats, representing a prevalence of 1:69. There were 127 carriers with >54 repeats, representing a prevalence of 1:113. Three asymptomatic women carried the fully mutated allele. Among the premutation and full-mutation carriers, 177 prenatal diagnoses were performed. Expansion occurred in 30 fetuses, 5 of which had an expansion to the full mutation. On the basis of these results, the expected number of avoided patients born to women identified as carriers, the cost of the test in this study (U.S. $100), and the cost of lifetime care for a mentally retarded person (>$350,000), screening was calculated to be cost-effective. Because of the high prevalence of fragile-X premutation or full-mutation alleles, even in the general population, and because of the cost-effectiveness of the program, we recommend that screening to identify female carriers should be carried out on a wide scale.
脆性X综合征由位于Xq27的FMR1基因中不稳定的CGG三核苷酸重复序列引起。中间等位基因(51 - 200次重复)在从母亲传递给后代时可扩展为完全突变。为评估脆性X携带者筛查项目的有效性,我们在1992年至2000年间对14334名以色列育龄妇女进行了脆性X携带者状态检测。这些妇女要么处于孕前状态,要么已怀孕,且无智力发育迟缓家族史。所有被发现携带前突变或完全突变等位基因的妇女均接受了遗传咨询,并在适用的情况下接受了产前诊断。我们鉴定出207名携带重复次数>50次等位基因的携带者,患病率为1:69。有127名携带重复次数>54次的携带者,患病率为1:113。三名无症状妇女携带完全突变的等位基因。在前突变和完全突变携带者中,进行了177次产前诊断。30例胎儿发生了扩展,其中5例扩展为完全突变。基于这些结果,考虑到被鉴定为携带者的妇女所避免出生的预期患者数量、本研究中检测的成本(100美元)以及智力发育迟缓者的终身护理成本(>350,000美元),计算得出筛查具有成本效益。由于脆性X前突变或完全突变等位基因的高患病率,即使在普通人群中也是如此,并且由于该项目具有成本效益,我们建议应广泛开展筛查以识别女性携带者。