Ginsberg G, Tulchinsky T, Filon D, Goldfarb A, Abramov L, Rachmilevitz E A
Ministry of Health, Jerusalem, Israel.
J Med Screen. 1998;5(3):120-6. doi: 10.1136/jms.5.3.120.
In Israel (population 5.7 million) there are around 200 known living subjects with thalassaemia major, of whom around 80% are from the northern district. This study aims at examining the costs and benefits of a national screening programme to prevent thalassaemia in Israel.
The lifetime healthcare costs of caring for a person born with thalassaemia major are $284,154. The costs of the home infusion service (33.1%) actually exceed the costs of the chelating agent itself (22.1%). The remaining 44.8% of costs are due to stay in hospital, operations, outpatient visits, laboratory tests, therapists, etc. Lost earnings and premature mortality costs account for a further $51,843 and $141,944 respectively for each case. A national screening programme would cost $900,197 and prevent around 13.4 homozygotes being born, at a cost of $67,369 for each birth prevented. The benefit-cost ratio of the programme to the health services is 4.22:1, which increases to 6.01:1 when a societal perspective is taken. However, around 13.0 homozygote births are still expected to occur, the majority owing to lack of compliance of patients at various stages in the screening process. The addition of a national health education programme for the higher risk non-Jewish population either nationally or in selected regions will incur extra costs, which may be covered by increased benefits as a result of better compliance with the screening programme.
Israel should start to provide a nationwide thalassaemia screening programme as the monetary benefits to society (and even to the health services alone) will exceed the screening programmes costs.
在以色列(人口570万),约有200名已知的重型地中海贫血在世患者,其中约80%来自北部地区。本研究旨在探讨以色列全国性预防地中海贫血筛查项目的成本与效益。
照顾一名重型地中海贫血患儿一生的医疗保健成本为284,154美元。家庭输液服务成本(33.1%)实际上超过了螯合剂本身的成本(22.1%)。其余44.8%的成本归因于住院、手术、门诊就诊、实验室检查、治疗师等费用。每名患者的收入损失和过早死亡成本分别为51,843美元和141,944美元。全国性筛查项目将花费900,197美元,可预防约13.4例纯合子出生,每预防一例出生的成本为67,369美元。该项目对卫生服务的效益成本比为4.22:1,从社会角度看则增至6.01:1。然而,预计仍会有13.0例左右的纯合子出生,大多数是由于患者在筛查过程的不同阶段不配合。在全国或选定地区为高风险非犹太人群增加一项全国性健康教育项目将产生额外成本,而更好地遵守筛查项目可能带来的效益增加或许可以弥补这些成本。
以色列应开始提供全国性的地中海贫血筛查项目,因为该项目对社会(甚至仅对卫生服务而言)的货币效益将超过筛查项目的成本。