Breen N, Caine D, Coltheart M
Macquarie Centre for Cognitive Science, Macquarie University, NSW 2109, Australia.
Neurocase. 2001;7(3):239-54. doi: 10.1093/neucas/7.3.239.
We present two patients in whom the mirror sign, the inability to recognize one's own reflected image, was a stable and persisting symptom signalling the onset of a progressive dementing illness. Extensive neuropsychological testing was conducted with both patients, with particular emphasis on face processing and the understanding of reflected space. Both patients were also investigated with structural imaging techniques (computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging). Although the neuroimaging results were not strongly lateralizing for either patient, neuropsychological testing revealed striking right hemisphere dysfunction with relatively intact left hemisphere cognitive function in both patients. Of particular interest was the patients' dissociation on tests of face processing; one patient, FE, had significant face processing deficits while the other patient, TH, had relatively intact face processing. Further testing with TH revealed striking deficits in his ability to interpret reflected space. The results of the face processing tests are discussed in the context of current models of normal face processing, with particular emphasis on the affective component in face recognition. We propose that a combination of cognitive deficits underlie the mirror sign delusion, including perceptual, affective and reasoning impairments, and also discuss the contributions of cortical and subcortical lesions in these two patients and in delusions in general.
我们报告了两名患者,他们存在镜像征,即无法识别自己的镜像,这是一种稳定且持续存在的症状,预示着进行性痴呆疾病的发作。对这两名患者均进行了广泛的神经心理学测试,特别侧重于面部处理和对反射空间的理解。还使用结构成像技术(计算机断层扫描和磁共振成像)对两名患者进行了检查。尽管神经影像学结果对任何一名患者都没有明显的定位倾向,但神经心理学测试显示,两名患者均存在明显的右半球功能障碍,而左半球认知功能相对完好。特别有趣的是患者在面部处理测试中的分离现象;一名患者FE存在明显的面部处理缺陷,而另一名患者TH的面部处理相对完好。对TH的进一步测试显示,他在解释反射空间方面存在明显缺陷。我们在当前正常面部处理模型的背景下讨论了面部处理测试的结果,特别强调了面部识别中的情感成分。我们提出,认知缺陷的组合是镜像征妄想的基础,包括感知、情感和推理障碍,还讨论了这两名患者以及一般妄想中皮质和皮质下病变所起的作用。