Li G, Shi Z, Jia H
Department of Heart-Kidney of TCM, China-Japan Friendship Hospital, Beijing 100029.
Zhongguo Zhong Xi Yi Jie He Za Zhi. 1998 Apr;18(4):208-11.
To observe the clinical effect of Garlicin on unstable angina pectoris (UAP) and to explore the relationship between Garlicin's effect and Syndrome Differentiation of TCM.
Fifty-five patients of UAP were divided randomly into the Garllcin group (34 cases) and the control group (21 cases) and classified based on Syndrome Differentiation of TCM into Cold Syndrome type, Heat Syndrome type, severe blood stasis (SBS) type or mild blood stasis (MBS) type. Garlicin 60 mg or nitroglycerin 5 mg were given to the two groups respectively by intravenous drip for 10 days as one therapeutic course. The curatic effect was evaluated by changes of symptoms and electrocardiogram, and some indexes, such as blood lipid, lipoprotein, apolipoprotein and GMP-140 among different groups and types were compared.
The difference of effective rate between the Garlicin group and the control group was insignificant. In the Garlicin group, the effective rate of Cold Syndrome type was higher than that of Heat Syndrome type (P < 0.01), and HDL/LDL ratio and apoA1 level raised markedly in the former type (P < 0.05) while an oppositive trend revealed in the Heat Syndrome type. Garlicin showed a higher effect on SBS type than that on MBS type and cause GMP-140 of the MBS type decreased obviously.
Garlicin is effective on UAP patients and its effect was more evident on those with Cold Syndrome type or SBS type. Its mechanism may be related to its effect in improving blood lipid and enhancing activation of platelet.
观察大蒜素治疗不稳定型心绞痛(UAP)的临床疗效,探讨大蒜素疗效与中医辨证的关系。
将55例UAP患者随机分为大蒜素组(34例)和对照组(21例),并根据中医辨证分为寒证型、热证型、重度血瘀(SBS)型或轻度血瘀(MBS)型。两组分别给予大蒜素60mg或硝酸甘油5mg静脉滴注,10天为一个疗程。通过症状和心电图变化评估疗效,并比较不同组和不同类型之间的血脂、脂蛋白、载脂蛋白和GMP - 140等指标。
大蒜素组与对照组有效率差异无统计学意义。大蒜素组中,寒证型有效率高于热证型(P < 0.01),寒证型HDL/LDL比值和apoA1水平明显升高(P < 0.05),而热证型呈现相反趋势。大蒜素对SBS型的疗效高于MBS型,且使MBS型的GMP - 140明显降低。
大蒜素对UAP患者有效,对寒证型或SBS型患者疗效更明显。其机制可能与其改善血脂及增强血小板活化作用有关。