Shi T J, Tandrup T, Bergman E, Xu Z Q, Ulfhake B, Hökfelt T
Department of Neuroscience, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
Neuroscience. 2001;105(1):249-63. doi: 10.1016/s0306-4522(01)00148-8.
Several types of changes have been reported to occur in dorsal root ganglia following peripheral nerve injury, including loss of neurons and increases and decreases in peptide expression. However, with regard to loss of neurons, results have not been consistent, presumably due to different quantitative methodologies employed and species analyzed. So far, most studies have been conducted on rats; however, with the fast development of the transgenic techniques, the mouse has become a standard model animal in primary sensory research. Therefore we used stereological methods to determine the number of neurons, as well as the expression of galanin message-associated peptide, a marker for galanin-expressing neurons, neuropeptide Y, and calcitonin gene-related peptide in lumbar 5 dorsal root ganglia of both control C57 BL/6J mice and in mice subjected to a 'mid-thigh' sciatic nerve transection (axotomy). In control animals the total number of lumbar 5 dorsal root ganglion neurons was about 12000. Seven days after axotomy, 24% of the dorsal root ganglion neurons were lost (P<0.001), and 54% were lost 28 days after axotomy (P<0.001). With regard to the percentage of peptide-expressing neurons, the results obtained showed that both galanin message-associated peptide (from <1% to about 21%) and neuropeptide Y (from <1% to about 16%) are upregulated, whereas calcitonin gene-related peptide is downregulated (from about 41% to about 14%) following axotomy. Results obtained with retrograde labeling of the axotomized dorsal root ganglion neurons indicate that the neuropeptide regulations may be even more pronounced, if the analysis is confined to the axotomized dorsal root ganglion neurons rather than including the entire neuron population. We also applied conventional profile-based counting methods to compare with the stereological data and, although the results were comparable considering the trends of changes following axotomy, the actual percentage obtained with the two methods differed markedly, both for neuropeptide Y- and, especially, for galanin message-associated peptide-positive neurons. These present results demonstrate that marked species differences exist with regard to the effect of nerve injury on dorsal root ganglion neurons. Thus, whereas no neuron loss is seen in rat up to 4 weeks after a 'mid-thigh' transection [Tandrup et al. (2000) J. Comp. Neurol. 422, 172-180], the present results indicate a dramatic loss already after 1 week in mouse. It is suggested that the proximity in physical distance of the lesion to the cell body is a critical factor for the survival of the target-deprived neurons. Finally, stereological methodology seems warranted when assessing the total number of neurons as well as changes in peptide regulations after axotomy in mouse.
据报道,外周神经损伤后背根神经节会发生几种类型的变化,包括神经元丢失以及肽表达的增加和减少。然而,关于神经元丢失,结果并不一致,推测是由于采用的定量方法和分析的物种不同。到目前为止,大多数研究是在大鼠身上进行的;然而,随着转基因技术的快速发展,小鼠已成为初级感觉研究中的标准模式动物。因此,我们采用体视学方法来确定对照C57 BL/6J小鼠以及接受“大腿中部”坐骨神经横断(轴突切断术)的小鼠腰5背根神经节中神经元的数量,以及甘丙肽信息相关肽(一种表达甘丙肽的神经元的标志物)、神经肽Y和降钙素基因相关肽的表达。在对照动物中,腰5背根神经节神经元的总数约为12000个。轴突切断术后7天,24%的背根神经节神经元丢失(P<0.001),轴突切断术后28天,54%的神经元丢失(P<0.001)。关于表达肽的神经元百分比,所得结果表明,轴突切断术后,甘丙肽信息相关肽(从<1%增加到约21%)和神经肽Y(从<1%增加到约16%)均上调,而降钙素基因相关肽则下调(从约41%降至约14%)。对轴突切断的背根神经节神经元进行逆行标记所得结果表明,如果分析仅限于轴突切断的背根神经节神经元而非包括整个神经元群体,神经肽的调节可能会更加明显。我们还应用传统的基于轮廓的计数方法与体视学数据进行比较,尽管考虑到轴突切断术后变化趋势,结果具有可比性,但两种方法获得的实际百分比差异显著,无论是对于神经肽Y阳性神经元,尤其是对于甘丙肽信息相关肽阳性神经元。目前的这些结果表明,神经损伤对背根神经节神经元的影响存在明显的物种差异。因此,虽然在大鼠“大腿中部”横断后4周内未见神经元丢失[Tandrup等人(2000年)《比较神经学杂志》422,172 - 180],但目前的结果表明小鼠在1周后就已出现显著的神经元丢失。提示病变与细胞体在物理距离上的接近程度是靶剥夺神经元存活的关键因素。最后,在评估小鼠轴突切断术后神经元总数以及肽调节变化时,体视学方法似乎是必要的。