Plaud J J
Cambridge Center for Behavioral Studies and Brown University, Concord, MA 01742-2107, USA.
J Clin Psychol. 2001 Sep;57(9):1089-102. doi: 10.1002/jclp.1125.
The debate between mentalism/cognitivism and behaviorism is analyzed, and it is concluded that behaviorism is the philosophy more closely associated with psychology as a behavioral science, the cognitive approach being more closely aligned with biological science. Specific objections to mentalistic interpretations of behavioral phenomena are detailed, and examples from clinical psychology are used to show the importance of behavioral approaches in applied domains. It is argued that the relation between behavior theory and clinical psychology is critical to the continued advancement of applied psychology. Behavior analysis is offered as a direct, applied extension of behavior theory as well as a highly practical and effective approach for understanding, explaining, and modifying the factors that contribute to and maintain maladaptive behaviors.
分析了心理主义/认知主义与行为主义之间的争论,得出的结论是,行为主义是与作为行为科学的心理学联系更为紧密的哲学,而认知方法则与生物科学联系更为紧密。详细阐述了对行为现象的心理主义解释的具体反对意见,并运用临床心理学的实例来说明行为方法在应用领域的重要性。有人认为,行为理论与临床心理学之间的关系对于应用心理学的持续发展至关重要。行为分析被视为行为理论的直接应用延伸,也是一种理解、解释和改变导致并维持适应不良行为的因素的高度实用且有效的方法。