Perlyn C A, Marsh J L, Pilgram T K, Kane A
Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Deformities Institute, St. Louis Children's Hospital, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, MO 63110, USA.
Plast Reconstr Surg. 2001 Aug;108(2):294-301. doi: 10.1097/00006534-200108000-00003.
Limited in vivo data exist on the dysmorphology of the cranial base in nonsyndromic craniosynostosis. Few studies have documented the effect of calvarial surgery for synostosis on endocranial morphology. Previous work has suggested that the dysmorphology of the endocranial base is diagnostically specific for metopic, sagittal, and unicoronal sutures. The purpose of this study was to further evaluate the endocranial base in infants with nonsyndromic craniosynostosis by testing the hypothesis that the dysmorphology is, to some degree, a secondary deformation rather than a primary malformation. Three questions were addressed: (1) Can individuals reliably identify affected suture-specific endocranial-base morphology using standard templates? (2) Does calvarial surgery in infancy for craniosynostosis affect the perception of endocranial-base morphology? and (3) Does calvarial surgery in infancy for nonsyndromic craniosynostosis normalize the endocranial base?In this study, three-dimensional volumetric reconstructions from archived computed tomography digital data were processed using the ANALYZE imaging software. Dysmorphology was assessed by nine independent, blinded skilled observers who reviewed two separate sets of images of endocranial bases. Both sets contained images from the same patients: one set contained preoperative images, and the other contained images of the endocranial base 1 year after calvarial surgery. Observers were asked to sort each set into four suture-specific diagnostic groups: normal, unicoronal, metopic, and sagittal. Each set contained 10 patients with unicoronal synostosis, 10 with metopic synostosis, 10 with sagittal synostosis, and four normal patients. Seventy-eight percent of the total number of preoperative images were correctly sorted into the suture-specific diagnostic group, whereas only 55 percent of the total number of postoperative images were correctly matched. With regard to the individual sutures, the results were as follows (data are presented as preoperative accuracy versus postoperative accuracy): metopic, 76 percent versus 44 percent; sagittal, 58 percent versus 34 percent; unicoronal, 100 percent versus 79 percent; and normal, 83 percent versus 72 percent. Although 36 of 306 total images per group (12 percent) actually represented normal patients, the observers called 72 of 306 normal (24 percent) in the preoperative set versus 110 of 306 normal (36 percent) in the postoperative set. In conclusion, (1) the endocranial dysmorphology of nonsyndromic craniosynostosis is recognizably specific to the affected suture; (2) calvarial surgery for nonsyndromic craniosynostosis normalizes the endocranial base qualitatively with regard to the diminished ability of raters to identify the primary pathology; and (3) the documented postoperative changes in endocranial base morphology after calvarial surgery for nonsyndromic craniosynostosis in infancy indicates that a major component of that dysmorphology is a secondary deformity rather than a primary malformation.
关于非综合征性颅缝早闭中颅底形态异常的体内数据有限。很少有研究记录颅骨手术治疗颅缝早闭对内颅形态的影响。先前的研究表明,内颅底形态异常对于额缝、矢状缝和单冠状缝具有诊断特异性。本研究的目的是通过检验以下假设来进一步评估非综合征性颅缝早闭婴儿的内颅底:即形态异常在某种程度上是继发性变形而非原发性畸形。研究解决了三个问题:(1)个体能否使用标准模板可靠地识别受影响的特定缝的内颅底形态?(2)婴儿期颅骨手术治疗颅缝早闭是否会影响对内颅底形态的认知?以及(3)婴儿期非综合征性颅缝早闭的颅骨手术是否能使内颅底正常化?在本研究中,使用ANALYZE成像软件对存档的计算机断层扫描数字数据进行三维容积重建。由九名独立、不知情的专业观察者评估形态异常,他们查看了两组单独的内颅底图像。两组均包含同一患者的图像:一组包含术前图像,另一组包含颅骨手术后1年内颅底的图像。观察者被要求将每组图像分为四个特定缝的诊断组:正常、单冠状缝、额缝和矢状缝。每组包含10名单冠状缝早闭患者、10名额缝早闭患者、10名矢状缝早闭患者和4名正常患者。术前图像总数的78%被正确分类到特定缝的诊断组,而术后图像总数中只有55%被正确匹配。就各个缝而言,结果如下(数据以术前准确率与术后准确率表示):额缝,76%对44%;矢状缝,58%对34%;单冠状缝,100%对79%;正常,83%对72%。尽管每组306张图像中有36张(12%)实际上代表正常患者,但观察者在术前组中将306张图像中的72张(24%)判定为正常,而在术后组中为306张中的110张(36%)判定为正常。总之,(1)非综合征性颅缝早闭的内颅形态异常对于受影响的缝具有明显的特异性;(2)非综合征性颅缝早闭的颅骨手术在内颅底方面定性地使其正常化,这体现在评估者识别主要病理的能力下降;(3)婴儿期非综合征性颅缝早闭的颅骨手术后记录的内颅底形态变化表明,该形态异常的主要成分是继发性畸形而非原发性畸形。