Lo L J, Marsh J L, Pilgram T K, Vannier M W
Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology, Washington University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Mo., USA.
Plast Reconstr Surg. 1996 Feb;97(2):282-91. doi: 10.1097/00006534-199602000-00003.
Plagiocephaly is a descriptive term that connotes an asymmetrically oblique or twisted head. Such cranial dysmorphology has a number of etiologies, the most common of which are unicoronal synostosis, unilambdoid synostosis, and plagiocephaly without synostosis. Use of the term plagiocephaly in the literature is often ambiguous in that at times it is used inclusively for all etiologies while at other times it is used exclusively as a synonym for unicoronal synostosis. Although differentiation by physical examination among unicoronal synostosis, unilambdoid synostosis, and plagiocephaly without synostosis usually is possible for an experienced observer, inexperienced observers often have difficulty making an anatomically accurate diagnosis even with the assistance of conventional skull radiographs. High-resolution CT scans, including three-dimensional osseous surface re-formations, have become a standard element in the evaluation of craniofacial anomalies in many centers. We hypothesized that the three major etiologies of plagiocephaly could be unambiguously differentiated by means of endocranial three-dimensional CT osseous surface re-formations. Archival pretreatment CT data on 15 unicoronal synostosis, 4 unilambdoid synostosis, and 15 plagiocephaly without synostosis patients were reviewed to define, qualitatively and quantitatively, the characteristics of the endocranial base morphologies for each group; in addition to visual dysmorphology specific to each group, there was a statistically significant difference in the angle of deviation from the midlines of the anterior and posterior cranial fossae among unicoronal synostosis, unilambdoid synostosis, and plagiocephaly without synostosis. Four radiologists experienced in reading images of craniofacial anomalies were oriented to the group characteristics and then instructed to perform differential diagnosis for each of the 34 patients using only the endocranial three-dimensional CT images. The raters were blind to all other clinical and diagnostic information. The raters correctly diagnosed unicoronal synostosis. Errors were made in differentiation of unilambdoid synostosis and plagiocephaly without synostosis. These errors resulted from the raters' reliance on image inspection rather than quantitation of anteroposterior fossae midline angulation. Such quantitation unambiguously differentiated between unilambdoid synostosis and plagiocephaly without synostosis in the "error" cases. The endocranial base dysmorphology of patients with plagiocephaly is etiology-specific for unicoronal synostosis, unilambdoid synostosis, and plagiocephaly without synostosis. Three-dimensional CT endocranial base images can assist differential diagnosis of plagiocephaly.
扁头畸形是一个描述性术语,指头部不对称倾斜或扭曲。这种颅骨畸形有多种病因,最常见的是单冠状缝早闭、单矢状缝早闭和非缝早闭性扁头畸形。文献中“扁头畸形”一词的使用常常含糊不清,有时它被广泛用于所有病因,而有时又专门用作单冠状缝早闭的同义词。尽管对于经验丰富的观察者来说,通过体格检查区分单冠状缝早闭、单矢状缝早闭和非缝早闭性扁头畸形通常是可行的,但即使借助传统的颅骨X光片,经验不足的观察者在做出解剖学上准确的诊断时也常常有困难。高分辨率CT扫描,包括三维骨表面重建,已成为许多中心评估颅面畸形的标准手段。我们假设通过颅内三维CT骨表面重建可以明确区分扁头畸形的三种主要病因。回顾了15例单冠状缝早闭、4例单矢状缝早闭和15例非缝早闭性扁头畸形患者的存档预处理CT数据,以定性和定量地确定每组颅内基底形态的特征;除了每组特有的视觉畸形外,单冠状缝早闭、单矢状缝早闭和非缝早闭性扁头畸形患者的前颅窝和后颅窝中线偏离角度在统计学上有显著差异。四位有阅读颅面畸形影像经验的放射科医生熟悉了各组特征,然后被要求仅使用颅内三维CT图像对34例患者中的每一例进行鉴别诊断。评估者对所有其他临床和诊断信息均不知情。评估者正确诊断了单冠状缝早闭。在区分单矢状缝早闭和非缝早闭性扁头畸形时出现了错误。这些错误是由于评估者依赖图像检查而非前后颅窝中线角度的量化。在“错误”病例中,这种量化明确区分了单矢状缝早闭和非缝早闭性扁头畸形。扁头畸形患者的颅内基底畸形对于单冠状缝早闭、单矢状缝早闭和非缝早闭性扁头畸形具有病因特异性。三维CT颅内基底图像有助于扁头畸形的鉴别诊断。