McCulloch M T
Research School of Earth Sciences, Australian National University, Canberra.
J R Soc West Aust. 1996 Mar;79 Pt 1:131-9.
The Earth's age and early differentiation history are re-evaluated using updated isotopic constraints. From the most primitive terrestrial Pb isotopic compositions found at Isua Greenland, and the Pilbara of Western Australia, combined with precise geochronology of these localities, an age 4.49 +/- 0.02 Ga is obtained. This is interpreted as the mean age of core formation as U/Pb is fractionated due to sequestering of Pb into the Earth's core. The long-lived Rb-Sr isotopic system provides constraints on the time interval for the accretion of the Earth as Rb underwent significant depletion by volatile loss during accretion of the Earth or its precursor planetesimals. A primitive measured 87Sr/86Sr initial ratio of 0.700502 +/- 10 has been obtained for an early Archean (3.46 Ga) barite from the Pilbara Block of Western Australia. Using conservative models for the evolution of Rb/Sr in the early Archean mantle allows an estimate to be placed on the Earth's initial Sr ratio at approximately 4.50 Ga, of 0.69940 +/- 10. This is significantly higher than that measured for the Moon (0.69900 +/- 2) or in the achondrite, Angra dos Reis (0.69894 +/- 2) and for a Rb/Sr ratio of approximately 1/2 of chondrites corresponds to a mean age for accretion of the Earth of 4.48 + /- 0.04 Ga. The now extinct 146Sm-142Nd (T1/2(146)=103 l0(6)yrs) combined with the long-lived 147Sm-143Nd isotopic systematics can also be used to provide limits on the time of early differentiation of the Earth. High precision analyses of the oldest (3.8-3.9 Ga) Archean gneisses from Greenland (Amitsoq and Akilia gneisses), and Canada (Acasta gneiss) do not show measurable (> +/- l0ppm) variations of 142Nd, in contrast to the 33 ppm 142Nd excess reported for an Archean sample. The general lack of 142Nd variations, combined with the presence of highly positive epsilon 143 values (+4.0) at 3.9 Ga, indicates that the record of large-scale Sm/Nd fractionation events was not preserved in the early-Earth from 4.56 Ga to approximately 4.3 Ga. This is consistent with large-scale planetary re-homogenisation during ongoing accretion of the Earth. The lack of isotopic anomalies in short-lived decay systems, together with the Pb and Sr isotopic constraints is thus consistent with core formation and accretion of the Earth occurring over an approximately 100 Ma interval following the formation of meteorites at 4.56 Ga.
利用更新后的同位素限制条件对地球的年龄和早期分化历史进行了重新评估。从格陵兰岛伊苏阿以及西澳大利亚皮尔巴拉地区发现的最原始的陆地铅同位素组成,结合这些地区精确的地质年代学,得出年龄为44.9±0.02亿年。这被解释为地核形成的平均年龄,因为由于铅被隔离到地球核心中,U/Pb发生了分馏。长寿命的Rb-Sr同位素体系为地球吸积的时间间隔提供了限制,因为在地球或其前身小行星吸积过程中,Rb因挥发损失而经历了显著亏损。对于西澳大利亚皮尔巴拉地块早期太古代(34.6亿年)重晶石,测得的原始87Sr/86Sr初始比值为0.700502±10。使用早期太古代地幔中Rb/Sr演化的保守模型,可以估计地球在约45.0亿年时的初始Sr比值约为0.69940±10。这显著高于月球(0.69900±2)或无球粒陨石安格拉·多斯雷斯(0.69894±2)的测量值,对于约为球粒陨石Rb/Sr比值一半的情况,对应的地球吸积平均年龄为44.8±0.04亿年。现已灭绝的146Sm-142Nd(T1/2(146)=1.03×10^6年)与长寿命的147Sm-143Nd同位素体系相结合,也可用于限制地球早期分化的时间。对格陵兰岛(阿米佐克和阿基利亚片麻岩)和加拿大(阿卡斯塔片麻岩)最古老(38 - 39亿年)的太古代片麻岩进行的高精度分析未显示出可测量的(>±10ppm)142Nd变化,这与一份太古代样品报道的33ppm 142Nd过剩情况形成对比。普遍缺乏142Nd变化,再加上在39亿年时存在高度正的ε143值(+4.0),表明从45.6亿年到约43亿年的早期地球中,大规模Sm/Nd分馏事件的记录未被保留。这与地球持续吸积过程中的大规模行星再均质化是一致的。短寿命衰变系统中缺乏同位素异常,以及铅和锶同位素限制,因此与在45.6亿年陨石形成后约1亿年的时间间隔内发生的地核形成和地球吸积是一致的。