Catipović V, Novalić D
Opća bolnica, 43000 Bjelovar.
Lijec Vjesn. 2001 May-Jun;123(5-6):111-6.
The aim of this paper was to point out the differences between groups of suicide attempters and suicides in prewar period in the Bjelovar-Bilogora county. The data about suicide attempt in patients were assembled from the Psychiatry Department of Bjelovar General Hospital in 1988-1990 period. The data about committed suicides in 1988-1998 period were assembled from Bjelovar-Bilogora police administration. That enabled the analyses of suicides realisation in a suicide attempters group. Sex rate differences were explained by differences in sex roles. Proportional relation between suicide and age and reverse proportional relation between suicide attempts and age was due to biological and psychosocial characteristics of the young and the old. Relation between self-destructive behaviour and appeal in suicidal behaviour was emphasized. Male suicide attempters were more often under the influence of alcohol which reflected alcoholism in general population. In suicide attempts men chose severe means more often than women. More frequent diagnosis of personal disorder in male suicide attempt group was explained by three factors: 1. Higher frequency of antisocial personal disorder in male population; 2. Psychiatrist tendency to avoid stigmatization of patients with personal disorder diagnosis, which has negative connotation of old concept of psychopathy; and 3. Psychiatrist tendency to use this diagnosis only for more serious forms of disruptive behaviour, such as antisocial personal disorder. Three characteristics were pointed out: 1. Low social sensitivity for suicidal behaviour; 2. Failure to instruct individuals to seek psychiatrist help; and 3. Individual hesitation to seek that help. This emphasized the need for the development of non-hospital psychiatry service, as well as the organization of continual psychiatric monitoring of regional epidemiological suicide data.
本文旨在指出战前比耶洛瓦尔-比洛戈拉县自杀未遂者和自杀者群体之间的差异。关于患者自杀未遂的数据收集自1988 - 1990年期间比耶洛瓦尔综合医院精神科。关于1988 - 1998年期间自杀者的数据收集自比耶洛瓦尔-比洛戈拉警察管理部门。这使得能够对自杀未遂者群体中的自杀实现情况进行分析。性别比例差异是由性别角色差异所解释的。自杀与年龄之间的比例关系以及自杀未遂与年龄之间的反比例关系是由于年轻人和老年人的生物学及社会心理特征所致。强调了自我毁灭行为与自杀行为吸引力之间的关系。男性自杀未遂者更常受到酒精影响,这反映了普通人群中的酗酒情况。在自杀未遂中,男性比女性更常选择极端手段。男性自杀未遂群体中个人障碍诊断更为频繁可由三个因素解释:1. 男性人群中反社会人格障碍的发生率较高;2. 精神科医生倾向于避免对被诊断为个人障碍的患者进行污名化,因为这带有旧有精神病概念的负面含义;3. 精神科医生倾向于仅将此诊断用于更严重的破坏性行为形式,如反社会人格障碍。指出了三个特征:1. 对自杀行为的社会敏感度低;2. 未指导个人寻求精神科医生帮助;3. 个人对寻求此类帮助犹豫不决。这强调了发展非住院精神科服务以及组织对区域流行病学自杀数据进行持续精神病学监测的必要性。