Yadav R S, Sampath R R, Sharma V P
Malaria Research Center, Field Station, Rourkela, Orissa, India.
J Med Entomol. 2001 Sep;38(5):613-22. doi: 10.1603/0022-2585-38.5.613.
In a malaria endemic area in Orissa state in eastern India baseline (November 1989 to October 1990) malaria incidence ranged front 215 to 328 cases/1,000 population/yr in different groups of villages. In November 1990, nylon bednets treated with deltamethrin at 25 mg/m2 were given out in two villages (population 1062), untreated bednets were given out in five villages (population 1,226) and in one village (population 786) nets were not given. Nets were retreated in October 1991 and June 1992 in treated-net villages. The trial continued until October 1992. The treated nets caused significant reduction in indoor resting density, biting (landing), light trap catches, human engorgement rate, and parous rate of malaria vector Anopheles culicifacies Giles as compared with untreated nets or no nets. Untreated nets also caused reductions in biting and indoor density. Treated nets retained insecticidal action well over 6 mo. In the final year, malaria incidence was reduced 8.9% in the no-net village, 34.9% in the villages with untreated nets, and 59.1% in villages with treated nets. The relative risk of malaria and parasite rates declined significantly in villages with treated nets. Pediatric splenomegaly rate did not change in the no-net village, increased significantly in villages with untreated nets, but decreased significantly in those with treated nets. Treated nets also reduced pediatric anemia rates, but Hb concentration increased in all villages. Considering the benefits of treated bednets and development of resistance among vectors to DDT and malathion, bednets treated with deltamethrin could be an effective alternative strategy to control malaria in forested areas in India.
在印度东部奥里萨邦的一个疟疾流行地区,基线期(1989年11月至1990年10月)不同村庄组的疟疾发病率在215至328例/1000人口/年之间。1990年11月,在两个村庄(人口1062)发放了用25毫克/平方米溴氰菊酯处理过的尼龙蚊帐,在五个村庄(人口1226)发放了未处理的蚊帐,在一个村庄(人口786)未发放蚊帐。在使用处理过蚊帐的村庄,于1991年10月和1992年6月对蚊帐进行了重新处理。该试验持续到1992年10月。与未处理的蚊帐或不使用蚊帐相比,处理过的蚊帐使疟疾媒介库氏按蚊在室内的栖息密度、叮咬(着陆)、诱蚊灯捕获量、人体饱血率和产蚊率显著降低。未处理的蚊帐也使叮咬和室内密度有所降低。处理过的蚊帐在超过6个月的时间里仍保持良好的杀虫作用。在最后一年,未使用蚊帐的村庄疟疾发病率降低了8.9%,使用未处理蚊帐的村庄降低了34.9%,使用处理过蚊帐的村庄降低了59.1%。使用处理过蚊帐的村庄中疟疾的相对风险和寄生虫率显著下降。在未使用蚊帐的村庄,儿童脾肿大率没有变化,在使用未处理蚊帐的村庄显著上升,但在使用处理过蚊帐的村庄显著下降。处理过的蚊帐也降低了儿童贫血率,但所有村庄的血红蛋白浓度都有所增加。考虑到处理过的蚊帐的益处以及媒介对滴滴涕和马拉硫磷产生抗性的情况,用溴氰菊酯处理的蚊帐可能是印度森林地区控制疟疾的一种有效替代策略。